Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Whoopie pies for birthdays in New York

A birthday cake is a commitment, but a whoopie pie offers the same celebration in a more manageable form.

Based on 678 Opinions
+675
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Sensible Edibles Bakery image 1
Sensible Edibles Bakery image 2
Sensible Edibles Bakery image 3
View all

Cozy bakery offers gluten-free oatmeal whoopie pies that taste just like traditional ones and feature seasonal flavors. Birthday cakes are delicious and allergen-friendly, perfect for diverse celebrations. Friendly cats and comfy seating create a warm, welcoming atmosphere.

Gluten-free oatmeal whoopie pies taste just like traditional ones. Seasonal options include fall pumpkin spice and winter whoopies. Allergen-friendly baked goods make these pies a solid choice.

Birthday cakes come out delicious and meet a variety of needs for celebrations. They work well for gatherings with different preferences.

People are saying

"I loved the delicious vegan baked goods, and they were dairy free too!"

"I loved their gluten-free cookies and muffins; they tasted amazing."

"The cakes here are so delicious and satisfying."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a wide variety of vegan and gluten-free desserts.

2

Half off on select items during the last hour on Fridays.

3

The entire kitchen is gluten-free, ensuring no cross-contamination.

02
The Sweet Life Bakeshop image 1

Bakery offers wide gluten-free selection and affordable coffee prices in a cozy, comfortable setting with pleasant jazz music. Regulars frequent the spot, enjoying homemade treats like exceptional cakes, croissants, and whoopie pies. The atmosphere invites relaxation, often with coffee by the window.

Special orders include themed cakes like Amalfi Coast and lemons. Cakes receive many compliments and inquiries. The flavor is consistently delicious.

People are saying

"The gluten-free cookies here taste amazing, you can't even tell."

"It's so cozy and welcoming, perfect for relaxing with coffee."

"I special ordered my birthday cake and it turned out stunning."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a variety of gluten-free options for those with dietary restrictions.

2

Prices for custom cakes are very reasonable compared to other bakeries.

3

There is limited seating inside, so plan accordingly during busy hours.

03
Fat Cardinal Provisions image 1

Bakery offers homemade donuts and a variety of freshly baked pastries with reasonable prices. Atmosphere feels inclusive and welcoming with a small counter and a red table outside for coffee enjoyment. Known for quality goods made on location and a homely neighborhood vibe.

Birthday cakes come with custom themes like a cars design that gets duplicated with precision. Ordering happens repeatedly, showing consistent satisfaction with their themed cake quality.

People are saying

"I found the custom cakes here to be beautiful works of art."

"You have to try their fresh, fluffy, not greasy donuts."

"They perfectly captured the details for my birthday cake idea."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers affordable prices for all items.

2

Quality goods are made on location for freshness.

3

The shop is a small takeout spot for quick visits.

04
Butterly Bakeshop image 1

Cozy spot with moist cupcakes and a warm atmosphere filled with fresh baked aromas. Pumpkin Whoopie Pies shine with cream cheese frosting and balanced pumpkin flavor. Birthday cakes impress with fresh, delicious taste and quick, reliable service.

Pumpkin Whoopie Pies feature a moist cookie with just the right pumpkin flavor and sweetness. The cream cheese frosting adds a rich, complementary touch.

Birthday cakes come out fresh, delicious, and attractive even with short notice. They rank among the yummiest in the city and have been a reliable choice for multiple years.

People are saying

"They recreated my custom cake design perfectly."

"This cookie's texture is unreal, perfectly crisp outside and chewy inside."

"They recreated my custom Birthday Cake design perfectly."

Good to know

1

The bakery is closed on Mondays.

2

The bakery offers great vegan and gluten-free options.

3

There is not much indoor seating available as the space is very narrow.

05
Ample Hills Creamery at The Social Brooklyn image 1

Colorful space combines indoor playground, pinball machines, and board game tabletops for a lively, family-friendly atmosphere. Music plays loudly, creating an energetic vibe that suits gatherings across generations. Ample seating indoors and outdoors supports both casual hangouts and kids' parties.

People are saying

"I found the ice cream here to be amazing and delicious."

"The kids' area was very thoughtful and the ice cream is amazing."

"I loved the original tastes and the option to make any flavor a milkshake."

Good to know

1

Customers can try a small sample of the flavors before choosing.

2

Customers may have to wait in line for 10 minutes even with only 2 people in front of them.

3

Doughnuts are only available on the weekends.

06
One Girl Cookies image 1
Cookie shop

Cookie shop offers a cozy ambiance with colorful window displays and curated products. Atmosphere stays laid back and welcoming, making it comfortable for work or casual meetups. Known for delicious baked goods, including standout cakes and whoopie pies.

Whoopie pies come in gorgeous, delicious varieties that kids love and adults find irresistible. They pair well with cookies and layer cakes, making for a sweet, satisfying treat.

People are saying

"I found the coffee here to be incredibly delicious."

"I found the cookies here to be insanely good."

"I found the whoopie pies gorgeous and delicious."

Good to know

1

One Girl Cookies offers cookies, whoopie pies, and birthday cakes.

2

The cafรฉ prepares lattes instead of flat whites.

3

The establishment has been open for over two decades.

07
Butterly Bakeshop image 1

Decor shines with stunning design and a weird vibe fills the air. Whoopie pies feature pink lemonade and gingerbread cream cheese frosting for sweet variety. Custom birthday cakes offer raspberry filling and funfetti with sprinkles, plus last-minute themed orders.

Offers pink lemonade and gingerbread cream cheese frosting whoopie pies. These provide a nice variety of sweet flavors.

Custom birthday cakes come with raspberry filling, funfetti with sprinkles, or vanilla buttercream options. Last-minute orders are possible, including themed designs like zodiac signs.

People are saying

"I found the cake to be delicious and fresh."

"This American Food's pumpkin pie is perfectly spiced and satisfying."

"I ordered a gorgeous custom birthday cake that everyone raved about."

Good to know

1

The bakery claims their cakes are made fresh daily and they donโ€™t sell day old items.

2

The cake should be taken out about an hour before cutting to reach room temperature.

3

The medium size of the cake is 6" in diameter.

08
Happy Zoe Vegan Bakery image 1

Small space with vintage ambiance and cozy seating creates a calm, homey vibe. Decor includes anti-leather signs and a style reminiscent of a southern thrift store. Energy stays relaxed, making it suitable for quiet conversation and casual visits.

Vegan birthday cakes come in beautiful, custom designs that suit allergy needs. The cakes are consistently delicious and visually appealing, with options like cheesecake also available.

People are saying

"This cake is so delicious, I can't stop eating it."

"These moist, delicious dairy-free cakes are perfect for birthdays."

"This birthday cake is the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The correct hours of operation are Tuesday to Sunday from 12 PM to 5 PM.

2

Everything is animal cruelty free and 100% vegan.

3

This bakery has many options for people with allergies to dairy, wheat, egg, and soy.

09
By the Way Bakery image 1

Small, cute spot with a cramped layout mainly for takeout. Whoopie pies offer a fluffy texture with sweet cream, standing out among treats. Birthday cakes are perfect for last-minute pick-up, all with a tempting baked goods aroma.

Whoopie pies have a nice fluffy texture with a central cream that can be a little too sweet. They stand out among other baked goods like almond cookies and cupcakes.

Offers birthday cakes suitable for last-minute purchases. Cakes come ready for pick-up without hassle.

People are saying

"I couldn't tell these delicious cakes were gluten free."

"These gluten-free and dairy-free brownies taste just like the real thing."

"These whoopie pies are truly the most delicious I have ever had."

Good to know

1

This bakery is not a vegan bakery.

2

The bakery offers gluten-free options for customers who are Celiac or gluten-sensitive.

3

There is no seating available at the location.

Discover more

New York, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...