Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in New York

Thrift footwear stores

A thrift store for shoes that actually curates its selection rather than forcing you to dig through piles of junk.

Based on 764 Opinions
+761
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
PaganBabyDolls Vintage Boutique image 1
PaganBabyDolls Vintage Boutique image 2
PaganBabyDolls Vintage Boutique image 3
View all

Vintage clothing store offers a well-curated selection of Y2K and 90s pieces with a mix of boho chic and euro summer styles. Atmosphere feels relaxed and welcoming with a charming, retro vibe. Clothing and accessories come in diverse sizes and styles, priced fairly for unique finds.

Offers a wide range of boots and platforms with many cute styles. Shoes come in broad sizes and pair well with belts and dresses for big occasions.

Offers a beautiful selection of vintage pieces including gothic tops, motorcycle leather jackets, and embroidered dresses. Curates 90s and Y2K treasures with a focus on vintage gowns and boho styles.

People are saying

"I found the cutest vintage Y2K clothes and treasures here."

"I love finding unique vintage pieces here."

"They have the best mix of Y2K and vintage styles."

Good to know

1

The boutique accepts credit cards and mobile payments for purchases.

2

Sales and promotions happen on the first Saturday of every month.

3

Returns are accepted within 14 days with a receipt.

02
Life Boutique Thrift image 1
Life Boutique Thrift image 2
Life Boutique Thrift image 3
View all

Two floors and a basement hold curated vintage clothing, unique home decor, and affordable prices. The atmosphere blends boutique charm upstairs with classic thrift vibes downstairs, creating a cozy and welcoming space. Neat organization and a diverse selection invite long browsing sessions.

Offers a wide range of shoes and boots at low prices, with some boots around $15. The lower floor features clothing and shoes mostly priced near $5, making it easy to find bargains.

Offers a great selection of vintage and affordable items with a focus on quality vintage clothing. Includes a diverse range of unique home decor alongside clothing.

People are saying

"I found so many lovely vintage dresses at this thrift store."

"I found a perfect pair of boots at this footwear store."

"This thrift store is one of the best around."

Good to know

1

The thrift store has seasonal events and sales.

2

There is a $5 basement full of clothes.

3

The store has multiple $5 racks in the downstairs area.

03
Hybrid Vintage image 1
Hybrid Vintage image 2
Hybrid Vintage image 3
View all

Small shop with curated vintage clothing offers a warm and inviting atmosphere reminiscent of an urban boutique. The space feels personal and well organized, showcasing affordable, high-quality pieces for men, women, and children.

Offers a large selection of shoes for all ages, including unique lime green Fluevog oxfords and adorable vintage baby shoes. Prices run about half the retail value, with items in excellent condition.

A curated selection of vintage clothing covers men's, women's, and kids' styles along with some designer bags. Prices suit every budget, offering affordable vintage finds that are hard to find elsewhere.

People are saying

"I love finding unique and quality vintage pieces here."

"The owner of this thrift store is the loveliest, friendliest person."

"The owner at this Footwear Store is so nice and sweet."

Good to know

1

The store has a great selection of clothing, shoes, bags, and jewelry for reasonable prices.

2

The children's section offers stylish clothing for infants and toddlers.

3

The vintage shop has a wide selection of pre-owned and true vintage clothing.

04
L Train Vintage image 1
L Train Vintage image 2
L Train Vintage image 3
View all

Sprawling thrift store with extensive layout and organized categories creates a sense of diving into vintage closets. Large, clean spaces feature walls covered in graffiti art, setting a unique urban vibe. The atmosphere hums with 80’s music, drawing a diverse crowd seeking affordable, well-priced vintage and used clothing.

Long lines form for shoes alongside other clothing items. The selection includes shoes with great deals available.

A sprawling thrift store offers a huge selection of vintage and second-hand clothing with great prices. Organized categories make it easy to find jackets, denim, and graphic tees among many other items.

People are saying

"This thrift store has great prices, like $6 Levis jeans."

"It's a big, affordable spot with organized vintage clothes."

"I found the footwear selection to be great and huge."

Good to know

1

Jackets are priced at $10 and Levis jeans at $6.

2

The dressing room is closed, so plan accordingly.

3

The store is not organized by size, making it a treasure hunt.

05
Awoke Vintage Brooklyn image 1
Awoke Vintage Brooklyn image 2
Awoke Vintage Brooklyn image 3
View all

Whimsical vintage clothing store with satin and floral decorations creates a unique shopping atmosphere. Loud music fills the space, adding to a lively vibe. Offers a curated selection of vintage Levi’s and trendy pieces, with frequent new inventory and a wide range of prices.

Selection includes cute heels and boots alongside other shoes. Variety covers shoes, hats, and jewelry.

A huge collection of one-of-a-kind vintage pieces fills the store, including a standout selection of vintage Levi’s shorts and jeans. Staff greet you promptly and offer thoughtful, attentive service.

People are saying

"I love finding unique vintage clothes and accessories here."

"I found so many cute vintage pieces at this thrift store."

"I found cute heels and boots in this footwear store."

Good to know

1

The store has fitting rooms inside so you can try on the clothes.

2

The largest size available is a Large and most items are cropped.

3

The prices are high.

06
Upper EastSide Thrift shop image 1
Upper EastSide Thrift shop image 2
Upper EastSide Thrift shop image 3
View all

Shop offers vintage and designer pieces packed into a tight, boutique-style space. Atmosphere feels quiet and uninviting without background music, contrasting with nearby busy spots. Prices remain surprisingly low for high-quality, unique items.

Offers a wide selection of shoes including Prada boots alongside clothes and vintage jewelry. Stock includes designer items like Gucci bags and Coach purses.

Shelves hold a wide range of vintage clothing, antiques, and unique handmade pieces. Prices stay low, with most shirts and pants under $5, alongside a solid mix of CDs, books, and vintage jewelry.

People are saying

"I found this thrift store to be the best I'd ever been to."

"I like how affordable and good this thrift store is."

"I found an amazing selection of shoes here."

Good to know

1

Thrift prices are $5 or less for most shirts and pants.

2

The thrift store offers a wide selection of jewelry, clothes, shoes, and home goods.

3

The selection includes vintage, unique, handmade, and designer pieces.

07
Urban Jungle image 1
Urban Jungle image 2
Urban Jungle image 3
View all

Huge thrift store with organized aisles and vast selection of clothes, shoes, and accessories. Busy atmosphere with a good vibe, attracting many shoppers including tourists. Offers ultra-affordable prices and ample space to browse through diverse vintage and new items.

A huge selection of shoes, clothes, and accessories fills the store. Prices often fall below $40 for shoes that usually cost hundreds. Boots stand out as a popular find here.

Huge variety of vintage pieces fills the spacious thrift store with endless options. Prices stay ultra-affordable, with items like a vintage Carhartt jacket or a fur coat each around $25.

People are saying

"I found this thrift store has a huge selection and really low prices."

"The thrift store has tons of great stuff and space."

"I found lots of popular footwear items here."

Good to know

1

Reserve 1-2 hours to browse the store for the best finds.

2

Bags must be left in lockers at the entrance.

3

Dressing rooms are closed; wear tight-fitting clothes to try on items.

08
Purdy Girl image 1
Purdy Girl image 2
Purdy Girl image 3
View all

Boutique space shines with sparkly atmosphere and chic vibe. Find cute shoes like boots paired with stylish accessories. Enjoy great sales on secondhand clothing, perfect for thrift lovers seeking bargains.

Cute shoes stand out with a variety that covers boots and more. The store offers a chance to build a full look, pairing footwear with accessories like earrings and bracelets.

Bargains abound with great sales and discounts on secondhand clothing. Several stores offer stellar options for thrift shopping.

People are saying

"I found the cutest shoes and dresses for every season here."

"I found amazing vintage designer finds and unique treasures here."

"I love finding unique vintage designer pieces here."

Good to know

1

The store has a great selection of on-trend clothes and accessories.

2

Purdy Girl offers excellent prices for women of all ages.

3

The boutique has a well-curated assortment of trendy clothing.

09
Mr Goods Buy & Sell image 1
Mr Goods Buy & Sell image 2
Mr Goods Buy & Sell image 3
View all

Consignment shop with a well-organized layout and eye-catching displays creates a quiet, serene atmosphere blending luxury and hypebeast culture. The environment feels welcoming and comfortable, attracting those interested in exclusive designer goods and fair, immediate transactions.

Offers a wide selection of designer shoes including Louis Vuitton, Gucci, and Dior. Provides good deals for selling and buying rare sneakers and sandals with consistent fair pricing.

Stock includes vintage Louis Vuitton bags, jackets, and sneakers at discount prices. Selling items is quick and easy with helpful staff.

People are saying

"I love scoring great deals on designer sneakers and bags here."

"The staff at this Footwear Store were so helpful and nice."

"I found amazing designer bags and sneakers at this thrift store."

Good to know

1

All items at Mr. Goods are authentic and high quality.

2

You can receive cash on the same day for your sold items.

3

Transactions are priced and negotiated quickly.

10
RGR Family Thrift Store image 1
RGR Family Thrift Store image 2
RGR Family Thrift Store image 3
View all

Spacious second hand store offers clean, fresh clothes and a bustling, energetic atmosphere with lively music. Shoppers find high-quality designer pieces and a wide selection including men's suiting and vintage styles. Cash and Apple Pay are accepted, with a single changing room available.

A wide range of designer shoes and dress shoes fills the shelves, including boots and sneakers that fit well. Prices stay low while offering high quality options across many styles and age groups.

Offers a wide range of items including vintage designer pieces and casual clothes at very fair prices. Accepts cash only and provides excellent service with notable discounts on second-hand treasures.

People are saying

"They have lots of shoes, but some are messy or pricey."

"I found great designer shoes and clothes at good prices."

"The staff at this Thrift Store are so nice and friendly."

Good to know

1

The thrift store is cash only, which can be inconvenient for customers.

2

You should come with cash for your purchases.

3

The prices at the thrift store are affordable and competitive.

11
Beacon's Closet image 1
Beacon's Closet image 2
Beacon's Closet image 3
View all

Store feels cramped and crowded with narrow aisles and tightly hung clothes, making browsing challenging. Music plays loud jazz, creating a vibrant and funky atmosphere. Organization is neat, with clothes sorted by color, and the selection includes unique vintage pieces.

An extensive selection of shoes and boots includes rare designer sneakers and Doctor Martens at affordable prices. Footwear options range from short boots to leather handbags, all in excellent condition.

Offers a unique selection of vintage and designer clothing with an amazing vintage shopping experience. Another spot nearby features a better selection of good, clean brands and respectful staff.

People are saying

"I found this thrift store to be the best I visited."

"I found a great selection of shoes and clothes at this footwear store."

"I think this is the best thrift store."

Good to know

1

Beacon's Closet allows you to sell items for 50% in store credit or 30% in cash.

2

Beacons has a new fitting room policy that requires customers to prioritize their first 6 items.

3

The store offers the best resale value for vintage items.

12
Crossroads Trading image 1
Crossroads Trading image 2
Crossroads Trading image 3
View all

Used clothing store with organized layout and clothes sorted by size and type. Atmosphere feels friendly with a clean, well-lit space and plenty of mirrors and dressing rooms. Offers a wide selection from basics to vintage designer items at affordable prices.

Offers a fantastic selection of vintage shoes alongside clothes. Buyers carefully inspect items, sometimes passing on popular brands like Nike or Ambush Air Force 1. Deals include hunter boots and True Religion boots found at good prices.

Offers a fantastic selection of vintage clothes, shoes, and designer items. Buys and sells across vintage, high-end designer, and streetwear categories with a strong eye for quality merchandise.

People are saying

"I found amazing designer vintage finds at this thrift store."

"I love finding vintage designer pieces here."

"I found brand new or barely worn shoes for a steal."

Good to know

1

The store offers a range of products at thrift and vintage prices.

2

The store accepts a variety of clothing types including vintage, high-end designer, and everyday streetwear.

3

The prices at the store are fair.

13
Out of the Closet - Brooklyn image 1
Out of the Closet - Brooklyn image 2
Out of the Closet - Brooklyn image 3
View all

Small thrift store offers well organized space with great selection of books and quality furniture. Prices vary, with some items overpriced but many found at good value. Atmosphere feels cheerful and supports a strong sense of community.

A wide selection of quality shoes includes boots that fit well in the fitting room area. Prices for shoes and other items stay very reasonable.

Selection varies and can be unpredictable, with some amazing bargains but also overpriced clothing for a thrift store. The space stays neat and in order, and the staff are friendly.

People are saying

"The store has great stuff at good prices."

"I found great furniture and home goods at this thrift store."

"I found great quality shoes at pretty great prices."

Good to know

1

Some clothing items are 50% off, specifically outerwear.

2

Dropping off items for donation is easy and done downstairs.

3

The store is very clean and well organized.

14
DSW Designer Shoe Warehouse image 1
DSW Designer Shoe Warehouse image 2
DSW Designer Shoe Warehouse image 3
View all

Four floors of spacious, brightly lit space showcase a vast selection of shoes organized by gender and style. Loud music and a bit of chaos create an energetic, lively atmosphere. Unique features include a waterfall by escalators and a footwear customization machine for personalized designs.

Four floors offer a huge selection of shoes for all genders and ages. A customization machine lets you print designs on select white sneakers. Staff provide friendly, helpful service to find the right fit.

People are saying

"I love that they have so many shoes at good prices."

"The staff at this footwear store are super friendly and attentive."

"The store has several floors just for shoes."

Good to know

1

Footwear customization services require an appointment.

2

Long checkout lines often result from complicated sales promotions.

3

If there's a large line at checkout, it's best to come back later.

15
City Opera Thrift Shop image 1
City Opera Thrift Shop image 2
City Opera Thrift Shop image 3
View all

Boutique thrift store offers carefully curated collections of high-end clothing and unique home furnishings spread across two levels. Bright, tidy space features a rotating inventory with global influences and stage prop origins. Atmosphere feels welcoming and comfortable, blending vintage charm with contemporary style.

Selection includes cowboy boots, fedora hats, and shoes in perfect condition. Variety covers purses and clothing alongside footwear.

Interesting, high quality items fill the store with a beautiful mix of contemporary and vintage clothing and home furnishings. Furniture downstairs and vintage pieces like molehair coats and cowboy boots stand out from typical thrift stores.

People are saying

"This thrift store has high-quality, curated items like designer clothes and unique home goods."

"I found unique, rare footwear and global-inspired clothing here."

"I think this place is more vintage than thrift."

Good to know

1

The thrift shop supports a worthy cultural cause.

2

Prices at the shop are more moderate than those at Goodwill or Housing Works.

3

The selection includes home furnishings, vintage glassware, coats, cowboy boots, and fedora hats.

16
The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center image 1
The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center image 2
The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center image 3
View all

Small thrift store offers organized clothing by color with generous discounts on certain tags. Prices remain affordable compared to nearby shops, despite some markup on popular fast fashion brands. Atmosphere includes old tunes playing and a steady flow of donations during open hours.

Variety of shoes greets you right at the entrance. Prices stay reasonable, and the store also offers a selection of books alongside footwear.

Offers a good mix of vintage and modern clothes with generous discounts on certain color tags. Prices stay fair with holiday sales and daily deals, making bargains easy to find.

People are saying

"The staff at this thrift store are so helpful and friendly."

"I loved the selection of shoes at this Footwear Store."

"They often have big discounts that make shopping worth it."

Good to know

1

This thrift shop is the most affordable compared to others nearby.

2

There is always a color sale item available.

3

The store has a variety of shoes at good prices.

17
Arc'teryx SoHo image 1
Arc'teryx SoHo image 2
Arc'teryx SoHo image 3
View all

Space combines modern lodge design with a chic minimal coffee shop and a vintage gear section downstairs. Atmosphere feels cool and cozy with comfortable music and a clean, fresh scent. Services include tailoring and gear repair, supporting both new and sustainable shopping experiences.

Shoes here offer comfort and sturdiness for hiking. The Norvan LD4 model fits well and prevents blisters and slipping during long walks.

A lower level houses a thrift section focused on vintage Arc'teryx gear for sustainable shoppers. The store also offers clothing repair and washing services with discounts on the β€œRe” brand.

People are saying

"The staff at this footwear store are so helpful finding the right shoes."

"The staff here are the most knowledgeable product specialists I've encountered."

"I felt comfy trying shoes in the rain."

Good to know

1

The store offers free on-site Gore wash and DWR treatment services year-round with a 3-day turnaround.

2

The ReGear section has unique finds, including one-off brand new items at a big discount.

3

The store features a repair shop downstairs called re-bird that repairs gear regardless of age or issue.

18
Thrift NYC image 1
Thrift NYC image 2
Thrift NYC image 3
View all

Small vintage clothing shop with quaint charm and cozy atmosphere. Walls display music band posters and original memorabilia, creating a unique vibe. Offers a large selection of jackets, band tees, and vintage Levi’s with fair prices reflecting quality.

A huge collection of cowboy boots stands out with a variety of toe shapes to choose from. Prices stay reasonable, and the selection includes Texan boots alongside vintage clothes and jackets.

Offers a large selection of vintage jackets, band tees, and Levi’s alongside unique items and some high-end Prada. Provides great bargains with a mix of vintage and quality pieces.

People are saying

"The Thrift Store staff are super friendly and helpful."

"The vintage clothes are unique but can be pricey."

"This footwear store has a crazy big collection of cowboy boots."

Good to know

1

The Ralph Lauren shirt costs $20.

2

The military style Harrington jacket costs $30.

3

The silk pants cost $34.

19
2nd STREET Lower East Side image 1
2nd STREET Lower East Side image 2
2nd STREET Lower East Side image 3
View all

Secondhand store offers a curated vintage selection with designer pieces like Yohji Yamamoto and Rick Owens. The atmosphere buzzes with fashion-focused energy and a unique mint scent fills the air. Clean and organized, it attracts shoppers seeking both affordable and luxury items.

Offers a curated selection of secondhand shoes and sneakers at various price points. Some sneakers appear worn but sell for nearly $100, while trade-in offers for shoes in good condition can be very low.

Offers a mix of luxury vintage clothes and curated thrift finds with an incredible designer selection including Westwood, Yohji, and Supreme. Prices lean toward the higher side, reflecting the quality and rarity of items.

People are saying

"I found an awesome mix of curated vintage and secondhand clothes here."

"They have amazing vintage designer clothes for less."

"The staff at this Footwear Store gave the best service I experienced."

Good to know

1

The store only accepts cash for purchases and sales.

2

Selling clothes can take a long time, with waits up to 3 hours.

3

You can only sell a maximum of 2 bags of clothes at a time.

20
Other People's Clothes image 1
Other People's Clothes image 2
Other People's Clothes image 3
View all

Bright space filled with natural light, plants, and color-coordinated clothing creates an inviting atmosphere. Loud, repetitive music plays throughout, giving the store a lively, upbeat vibe. Organized by item and color, it offers a boutique thrift experience with a wide variety of quality used clothes.

A strong selection of shoes and clothes fills the shelves, with various sizes available. Staff members offer kind and helpful assistance, making it easy to find great shoes and sneakers.

Affordable and exciting pieces include a wide selection of vintage clothes and fast fashion. Leather jackets, trench coats, and vintage sweaters in perfect condition appear regularly.

People are saying

"I found amazing vintage clothes and unique outfits at this thrift store."

"I love finding affordable vintage clothes here."

"The staff at this Footwear Store were so kind and helpful."

Good to know

1

The store offers a great selection of used clothes, especially plus-size options.

2

Prices are reasonable compared to full retail for higher-end pieces.

3

The store is well-organized, making it easy to find items.

Discover more

New York, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...