Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots for gefilte fish to Enjoy in New York City

Based on 641 Reviews
+638
User
User
User
Updated
01
Fish N' Dish image 1
Fish N' Dish image 2
Fish N' Dish image 3
View all

Fish N' Dish

๐ŸŸ Gefilte Fish
๐Ÿฆž Seafood
๐ŸŸ Fish
๐ŸŸ Salmon
More

State-of-the-art fish store offers exceptional freshness and a spotless, odor-free environment. Gefilte Fish here has an amazing flavor and ranks as the best in town. Modern design enhances the clean, fresh atmosphere.

People are saying

"The fish here is always fresh and clean."

"The store looks modern and really beautiful."

Good to know

1

The store offers fresh fish daily, sourced from local fishermen.

2

Expect a variety of seafood options, including shellfish and seasonal catches.

3

Parking is available on-site, but it can fill up quickly during peak hours.

02
Meal Mart image 1
Meal Mart image 2
Meal Mart image 3
View all
๐ŸŸ Gefilte Fish
๐Ÿฅ˜ Food
๐Ÿ— Chicken Soup
๐Ÿ– Chopped Liver
More

Takeout spot offers heimish atmosphere with a friendly vibe. It features affordable prices and a great selection for Shabbos or weekday needs.

People are saying

"The prices are great and the food tastes good."

"The food is fresh and tastes amazing."

"The takeout food is fresh and light."

Good to know

1

The store offers a wide selection of items for Shabbos and weekdays.

2

Prices are affordable compared to other stores in the neighborhood.

3

It is primarily a takeout restaurant with no dine-in options.

03
Mermelstein Takeout image 1
Mermelstein Takeout image 2
Mermelstein Takeout image 3
View all
๐ŸŸ Gefilte Fish
๐Ÿฅ˜ Food
๐Ÿท๏ธ Cheap
๐Ÿคซ Quiet
More

Small kosher restaurant offers affordable prices and straightforward folk food with some tables for eating in. Atmosphere feels heimish and cosy, quiet with a simple, old-fashioned setup. Known for catering and takeout, it serves food with a taste of home.

People are saying

"I love the classic, authentic kosher dishes here."

"The place feels cozy and affordable but needs updating."

"The homemade food tastes great even if simple."

Good to know

1

There is a $7 entry fee.

2

The cost of the shawarma is $17.

3

The restaurant serves traditional catered dishes.

04
Gourmet Island image 1
Gourmet Island image 2
Gourmet Island image 3
View all
๐ŸŸ Gefilte Fish
๐Ÿ…ฟ๏ธ Parking Available
๐Ÿฅ— Healthy Foods
๐ŸŽฏ Authentic
More

Supermarket combines authentic Slavic food with a phenomenal bakery and a fresh floral department. Spacious and visually appealing layout creates an inviting and cozy atmosphere. Shoppers find a wide selection of fresh produce and quality products in a friendly environment.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh and tastes great."

"They offer a great variety of fresh foods at good prices."

"The staff are friendly and always ready to help."

Good to know

1

The store offers a wide selection of Ukrainian products.

2

Parking is free and spacious for customers.

3

The bakery provides fresh baked goods daily.

05
Sable's Smoked Fish image 1
Sable's Smoked Fish image 2
Sable's Smoked Fish image 3
View all
๐ŸŸ Gefilte Fish
๐Ÿฅ— Salad
๐Ÿฆž Lobster
๐Ÿฆž Seafood
More

Smoked fish takes center stage with an incredible range and exceptional quality that draws locals. The atmosphere feels old school and family-owned, offering both indoor and outdoor seating. Bagels accompany the fish, though they lack the classic chewiness found elsewhere.

People are saying

"I love their fresh smoked fish and tasty sides."

"The belly lox is pricey and less flavorful here."

Good to know

1

Breakfast is under $5 and lunch is under $15, including hot soup.

2

The price for a sandwich is $12.

3

The belly lox was $60 per pound, which is 50% more than at Zabarโ€™s or Fairway.

06
Russ & Daughters image 1
Russ & Daughters image 2
Russ & Daughters image 3
View all
๐ŸŸ Gefilte Fish
๐Ÿฒ Matzo Ball Soup
๐Ÿฆž Seafood
๐ŸŸ Fish
More

Bagel shop with a retro style and modern, sleek design offers free cream cheese samples and self-serve seating. Atmosphere shifts from peaceful and pleasant during slow times to loud and crowded on busy days. Staff are knowledgeable and helpful, enhancing the friendly and energetic vibe.

People are saying

"The bagels and smoked fish taste amazing here."

"This place is a must-visit for bagel lovers despite the wait."

"The sandwiches are fresh and tasty but sometimes mixed up."

Good to know

1

You need to get a ticket before ordering to join the queue.

2

Expect to wait at least 30 minutes during peak hours.

3

To avoid the wait, consider ordering online for pickup.

07
Citarella Gourmet Market - West Village image 1
Citarella Gourmet Market - West Village image 2
Citarella Gourmet Market - West Village image 3
View all
๐ŸŸ Gefilte Fish
๐ŸŸ Fish
๐Ÿ›’ Grocery Store
๐Ÿงบ Market
More

Small, well-organized gourmet grocery store offers wide selection of fresh fish, meats, and produce. Atmosphere carries a strong seafood smell with a fun vibe and interesting brands throughout. Shoppers find many hard-to-find items and enjoy quality bakery goods and prepared meals.

People are saying

"The food is fresh and tasty, though pricey."

"They have an awesome variety of meals and products."

Good to know

1

The grocery store has an extremely good and fresh selection of seafood daily.

2

In-store purchases can only be returned within 24 hours.

3

Customers should check freshness dates when ordering pre-cooked items.

08
Grill On Lee image 1
Grill On Lee image 2
Grill On Lee image 3
View all
๐ŸŸ Gefilte Fish
๐Ÿ• Kosher
๐Ÿฅ˜ Food
๐Ÿ“ป Vintage
More

Kosher restaurant offers a large, clean seating area with a casual, energetic vibe. It serves an elaborate, diverse menu featuring well-regarded pastrami sandwiches and cholent. Prices are generally fair to high compared to other options in the area.

People are saying

"I loved the fresh, tasty food and chill vibe."

"I was frustrated by slow service and bad food."

"I really enjoy their authentic kosher comfort food."

Good to know

1

Delivery is available within 45 minutes for cash orders.

2

The restaurant features a special pre-Shabbat menu on Thursday nights.

3

Prices range from $15 to $25 for main dishes.

09
Gottlieb's Restaurant image 1
Gottlieb's Restaurant image 2
Gottlieb's Restaurant image 3
View all
๐ŸŸ Gefilte Fish
๐ŸŽฏ Authentic
๐Ÿ• Kosher
๐Ÿฅ˜ Food
More

Old-school kosher diner with 1970s decor offers a cozy, classic vibe. Fresh gefilte fish is a standout, praised by staff and locals. The place hosts an Ultra Orthodox crowd, preserving a true Brooklyn Jewish feel.

People are saying

"The pastrami and traditional dishes taste authentic and satisfying."

"The place feels like a classic spot but the tipping feels high."

"The food tastes fresh and delicious every time."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, and you can take out or eat in.

2

A 15% tip is automatically added to your bill.

3

Expect to pay around $30 for a small sandwich.

10
Sargeโ€™s Delicatessen & Diner image 1
Sargeโ€™s Delicatessen & Diner image 2
Sargeโ€™s Delicatessen & Diner image 3
View all
๐ŸŸ Gefilte Fish
๐Ÿฐ New York Cheesecake
๐Ÿฒ Matzo Ball Soup
๐Ÿฅช Deli
More

Quintessential New York deli with nostalgic decor and a classic diner vibe. Gefilte fish is very tender and pairs well with chopped liver or a soup and sandwich combo. Cozy, bustling interior with huge booths perfect for groups.

People are saying

"I love the classic pastrami and corned beef sandwiches here."

"The cheesecake slices here are huge and absolutely delicious."

"The egg creams can be hit or miss, but some are quite good."

Good to know

1

The average person should share a plate due to the size of the portions.

2

They add a 3.5% surcharge when you pay your bill with any credit card.

3

If you pay with cash, they will take 5% off the bill.