Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 hidden-gem gelato spots to Discover in New York City

Based on 715 Reviews
+712
User
User
User
Updated
01
Figo il Gelato Italiano image 1
Figo il Gelato Italiano image 2
Figo il Gelato Italiano image 3
View all
💎 Hidden Gems
🍨 Gelato
🍦 Ice Cream
🍫 Chocolate
More

Small ice cream shop offers rich gelato with flavors like Dubai chocolate that impress deeply. Cozy, authentic Italian vibe creates a warm atmosphere with heated outdoor seating. Known as a hidden gem, it surprises many with its unique charm and generous tastings.

People are saying

"The gelato flavors here are unbelievably delicious."

"I had the best gelato I've ever experienced."

"I love trying all the great gelato flavors here."

Good to know

1

Figo's is open until midnight for late-night gelato cravings.

2

Each month features seasonal specials to try.

3

The gelato is served in the same size cup for all servings.

02
Rito Gelato image 1
Rito Gelato image 2
Rito Gelato image 3
View all
💎 Hidden Gems
🍨 Gelato
🍦 Ice Cream
🍫 Chocolate
More

Gelato shop with clean layout and clearly labeled flavors offers a cozy, welcoming vibe. Staff prepare gelato and sorbet on site using traditional Roman recipes. The place draws a steady crowd seeking premium quality gelato with a variety of creative flavors.

People are saying

"The gelato here is delicious, rich, and incredibly smooth."

"The gelato tastes smooth and just like Italy."

"I think this gelato beats others around here."

Good to know

1

Rito Gelato just opened, offering a fresh selection of gelato.

2

The owner makes gelato and sorbet on-site using traditional recipes.

3

Rito Gelato offers about 11 flavors of gelato and many creative sorbet options.

03
Sorso' image 1
Sorso' image 2
Sorso' image 3
View all
🍨 Gelato
💎 Hidden Gems
❤️ Intimate
🛋️ Cozy
More

Small, elegant wine bar offers an intimate and cozy atmosphere with warm lighting and quiet ambiance ideal for conversation. Guests enjoy an amazing wine selection paired with innovative small plates inspired by authentic Italian cuisine. Music enhances the experience without overpowering the relaxed vibe.

People are saying

"I love the cozy vibe and amazing wine here."

"I can't wait to come back again soon."

"I found this place to be a cozy and sophisticated hidden gem."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6 PM with wine and bruschetta for $15.

2

The café offers a deal of two glasses of wine for $20 during happy hour.

3

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially on weekends.

04
Venchi Chocolate & Gelato UES image 1
Venchi Chocolate & Gelato UES image 2
Venchi Chocolate & Gelato UES image 3
View all
💎 Hidden Gems
🍨 Gelato
🍦 Ice Cream
🌰 Pistachio
More

Chocolate shop offers an authentic Italian vibe with a beautiful, elegant setting and cozy ambiance. Bright lighting contrasts with friendly, joyful atmosphere and free samples enhance the experience. Indoor and outdoor seating provide comfortable spots to enjoy rich chocolates and gelato.

People are saying

"I found the gelato here to be insanely good and fresh."

"I love how creamy and authentic the gelato tastes here."

"The gelato flavors are amazing, especially the pistachio."

Good to know

1

There is no bathroom available in the ice cream parlor.

2

Prices for a cup or cone with a topping are almost $11 for the regular size.

3

Sorbets are placed in the same area as allergens without separation.

05
Yawdie image 1
Yawdie image 2
Yawdie image 3
View all
🍨 Gelato
💎 Hidden Gems
🦐 Coconut Shrimp
🍔 Sliders
More

Small space decorated with Caribbean heritage and island-inspired decor creates a cozy, welcoming vibe filled with ukulele music. Atmosphere feels like a family gathering with warm, happy faces and serene energy. Regular workshops and occasional treats add to the engaging cultural experience.

People are saying

"I found Yawdie to be an amazing hidden gem."

"I love finding hidden gems that feel vibrant and clean."

"I think this place is a real local hidden gem."

Good to know

1

Every Sunday, they give away free ice cream.

2

Fried plantain strips are available upon request.

3

The restaurant is very allergen friendly.

06
Like A Local Tours image 1
Like A Local Tours image 2
Like A Local Tours image 3
View all
💎 Hidden Gems
🍨 Gelato
🏘️ Local Spot
🤔 Interesting
More

Small groups walk through vibrant markets and scenic rooftops, enjoying a slow-paced, relaxed vibe with upbeat energy. The tour blends architectural views and local culture, offering tasty bites from diverse, well-curated food stops without feeling rushed or like a lecture.

People are saying

"I loved how the tour mixed tasty food with cool history and culture."

"Justin made the tour fun with his great stories and knowledge."

Good to know

1

Participants should arrive hungry as the tour includes multiple food tastings.

2

Guides provide rich historical context about the neighborhoods visited during the tour.

3

The Brooklyn Heights and DUMBO tour includes a walk on the Brooklyn Bridge.

07
Mediterra Cafe image 1
Mediterra Cafe image 2
Mediterra Cafe image 3
View all
💎 Hidden Gems
🍨 Gelato
🇮🇹 Italian Food
🍰 Cannoli
More

Small, cozy café with authentic Italian atmosphere and loud music that fills the space. Comfortable indoor and outdoor seating includes a heated cabin outside. Frequented by those seeking Neapolitan pastries and strong cappuccinos with a welcoming, warm vibe.

People are saying

"I love their authentic Italian pastries and sandwiches."

"Cerasella has the best authentic Italian pastries and coffee."

Good to know

1

Cerasiello has $12.95 lunch specials Mon-Fri from 12pm-3pm.

2

Be sure to call ahead to make sure Cerasiello is open.

3

Cerasiello's hours are believed to be 11am-8pm.

08
Foods of NY Tours image 1
Foods of NY Tours image 2
Foods of NY Tours image 3
View all
💎 Hidden Gems
🍨 Gelato
🥘 Food
🤔 Interesting
More

Sightseeing tours blend rich history with lively neighborhoods and charming eateries. Food tours reveal hidden gems and unique local flavors. Ending with chocolate gelato offers a sweet, popular treat loved by all ages.

People are saying

"Joe made sure our 9-year-old felt included by getting him chocolate gelato."

"Everyone loved the tacos, pizza, and gelato."

"The tour had a great mix of foods ending with gelato."

Good to know

1

The tour lasts for 3 hours in lower Manhattan.

2

Most of the tour is indoors, good for weather concerns.

3

Don't eat too much before the tour to enjoy the food.

09
Ahoy New York Food Tours image 1
Ahoy New York Food Tours image 2
Ahoy New York Food Tours image 3
View all
💎 Hidden Gems
🍨 Gelato
🧭 Food Tours
🤔 Interesting
More

Small group tours explore neighborhoods with a friendly, relaxed vibe and intimate atmosphere. The experience blends local history with diverse food tastings, including standout dumplings, gnocchi, and roasted duck. Views of urban parks and waterfronts add to the engaging city exploration.

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to secure your spot on the food tour.

2

The tour includes tastings from various restaurants in Little Italy and Chinatown.

3

Expect to learn about the history of the neighborhoods during the tour.

10
Osteria La Baia image 1
Osteria La Baia image 2
Osteria La Baia image 3
View all
💎 Hidden Gems
🍨 Gelato
🍽️ Dinner Spots
🥘 Food
More

Italian restaurant combines elegant decor with cozy, warm atmosphere featuring live music and an open kitchen. Indoor and outdoor seating accommodate various group sizes and weather conditions. Bar offers exceptional cocktails alongside exquisite Italian cuisine.

People are saying

"The food was fresh and really delicious."

"The atmosphere made the whole night special."

"You have to try the pasta; it's a flavor explosion."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended as the restaurant is always busy.

2

Brunch is served on weekends with cocktails, appetizers, entrees, and dessert.

3

Expect to spend between $130 to $150 per person for dinner.