Top 8 Gluten-Free Bakeries to Delight in Key West

E. E.

Gluten free key lime pie (!!!) that tasted GOOD. Sometimes gf is not yummy and I have celiac disease so no choice. We bought a pie and brought it back to our hotel to eat over the 4 days we spent in Key West.

Scott Allison

Looks good but as of February 2025 no gluten free pie option.

Raquel Setterlund

I come here every time I visit for their delicious coffee and the gluten free pistachio lemon cake. This visit, I treated myself to a birthday breakfast and it did not disappoint. Everything was fresh and the flavors were amazing.

Natasha Brown

Gluten free key lime pie so you don't feel left out on the key west experience!

Lori Boyle

We enjoyed our visit and always have a nice experience. I would come more often if there were more gluten free and vegan options. My sister joined us and wasn’t able to try anything since she is vegan. Maybe a simple apple crisp or similar could be offered??

Terry Ballentine

Great Ice Cream. Gluten Free options

Jana Bravo

We went and ate at the location one time and had them deliver to our resort two other times. I eat gluten free due to Celiac and I was able to safely eat here. The two times we ordered delivery were great experiences. The food came sooner than expected both times. Also the order was 100% accurate which unfortunately surprises me since there is usually a mistake somewhere in food delivery. We ordered directly from their website instead of a meal delivery company. Their website is very user friendly and everything is customizable. I wish they had a location near where I live.

Choppers368

This was a good ice cream spot; the ice cream is especially creamy which suggests to me that it has a higher cream content. The key lime pie was quite tasty; sweet yet tart and had a thick yummy buttery graham cracker crust. The gentleman added some whipped cream as this is not the “meringue topped” type of key lime pie. We also had some Cuban cappuccino which was essentially an Italian cappuccino but it was very good. The gentleman serving us surprised us with a taste of an affogado (espresso and some vanilla ice cream) which was really tasty! There are also giant cookies, fudge, gluten free chocolate macaroons but we did not try those. The ice cream is made down the street but it is essentially made on site as is the key lime pie. Good place!