Absolutely fantastic restaurant. Great food, great atmosphere, and great staff. Life is good when Arnie is behind the bar. My only recommendation is that they add a gluten free bun/bread option for their burgers and sandwiches. And it’s a no brainer too as they could add an extra $2-3 charge for the buns that pays for them instantly, especially since the Trader Joe’s gluten free buns are less than $5 for a pack of 4. Even if they never officially add it to the menu they’ll let you bring in a gluten free buns yourself and they’ll make you a burger or sandwich with the GF bun.
TL;DR Magpies grill is a La Cañada staple and an absolute must-visit. Great for eating in and for take out, and they’ll treat you like royalty either way.