My wife and I have been here twice so far. Both times we've had a flawless experience. The food is excellent (with good gluten-free options), the atmosphere is lovely, and the staff are warm and accommodating.
This latest trip was for a wedding anniversary. Upon hearing this, we were offered a celebratory dessert on the house.
It's the little touches.
Final note: love the humorous Mafia themed menu! Like their seafood section titled "sleeping with the fishes". Hilarious!