Top 14 Gluten-Free Late-Night Spots to Enjoy in Westerville

Lara Ellis

Lots of gluten free options. Delicious food and good service.

Vicki A

Great gluten free options!! Waitress marked my order celiac so they took extra precautions. Lots to pick from off the menu.

Nancy Sirivanakarn

My husband and I had a lovely date night at Asterisk Supper Club on 2/7/25. We ordered the Caesar salad, center cut steak with Burgundy Mushroom Demi, and Ratatouille. For dessert, we shared a chocolate torte that was vegan, gluten free and nut free. Everything was SO delicious! (Sorry, I didn’t take any pictures of our food. I can assure you, it all looked amazing and we devoured it.) Our waiter, Nick, was very nice, friendly and attentive, and we enjoyed the ambience. Being an avid reader, my husband liked all the books on the shelves, and picked one out to read as we waited for a table. Which leads me to say, I highly recommend making a reservation beforehand. We also very much enjoyed the live entertainment of beautiful singing and guitar playing. Thank you, Asterisk Supper Club, we had a great time!

Mer

Really disturbing response from owner. Unsafe. I’ve reported it to Google. If you have allergies, this is not a safe space. I asked about gluten cross contamination for celiac and was told to go cook at home (literally) 🙄. GF and non GF items on mixed surfaces intermingling. I wouldn’t have minded if the owner hadn’t talked to me like I was a moron. I don’t mind if a place doesn’t have safe offerings, but just say “No, we don’t,” rather than going on a rant about how annoying people with autoimmune diseases are. If I could leave negative stars I would.

Pam Senek

I love cardinal pizza and we frequent it a lot. I usually order a gluten free pizza and other items for my family. What I love is that pick up is smooth. I love the food. It is hard to get a seat but it is a small place so we’ve resorted to takeout now. However the last few times ordering by phone I have been met with cardinal pizza can you hold please and then they don’t wait for a reply and the phone slams down. I get they are busy but that is a bit off putting. Perhaps having more help so they aren’t as stressed could be helpful. Tonight when I ordered the same thing happened. I waited on hold. When she came back on she couldn’t hear me. Instead of saying I can’t hear you I was hung up on. I called back and the same thing happened and I was placed on hold in the same manner. Then our order is missing ranch every time. My son likes his sub with ranch and a salad Cesar dressing. It has been missed the last few times we’ve ordered even though I was really specific this time when I ordered. It is marked correctly on the receipt. While this is minor in conjunction with the phone situation it isn’t very welcoming. We still love the food!

Ray Stephens

My wife and I have been customers for quite a long time sometimes my pizza is poor last time pizza was delicious my wife Sub is always good 👍 i am gluten free , we will keep coming

Shauna Wilson

Love there chips. Great gluten free options. Fun atmosphere

Rebecca explores the world

If you follow the GPS finding this restaurant isn’t hard, just a little awkward to turn into. Parking was great. It has a large lot. I ordered these super herd burger with buffalo meat. It was pretty tasty until I got to the middle where it was more pink than I would like it to be. The server did not ask how I liked it cooked. The gluten free bun wasn’t bad. The real winner was the sweet potato fries. They tasted like fair fries with the brown sugar glaze on them! It was busy but the server seemed aloof and neglected us somewhat. We sat at booth that had a TV with a baseball game on. When that was over we asked if they could switch it to another baseball game that was going on and we were informed that all the TVs are on the same circuit and they couldn’t change it because other people were watched the game that just ended?? Seems odd. Maybe they just weren’t Reds fans? LOL

Liz Love

Had a wonderful happy hour here the other day. I loved the honey cider and loaded tots. The gluten-free options were fantastic!

Eleanor Carty

M A

Best & most delicious gluten free pizza. They get busy and it is far easier to order on the ap & pick it up yourself. We like the cauliflower pizza but really love the regular gluten free pizza.

James Hatcher

Dominick Smith

Ryan Hassmann

Been our go to pizza place recently. Best gluten free pizza we’ve found around the area. Typically order for pick up and it’s usually ready on time. The normal thin crust is great too. Definitely recommend!