Top 8 Gluten-Free Pizza Joints to Relish in Barnstable

Sarah S

This is our go to pizzeria when visiting the Cape! The restaurant is beautiful and the staff is always attentive and friendly. They have a nice selection of specialty pizzas. I have a gluten sensitivity so I ordered the Pistachio Pesto pizza on GF crust and it was wonderful! My husband ordered the forest mushroom and my daughter had a classic cheese pizza. You can't beat their weekday lunch special! A pizza, salad and beverage for $16! Such a steal for a place this good!

Danielle Hardie (Dani)

I recently visited Not Your Average Joe's and was pleased to find a variety of gluten-free options on the menu. The food was tasty, but unfortunately, the prices didn't quite match the quality and portion sizes. I felt it was a bit overpriced for what we received. The service was just okay. Our server seemed friendly, but when we asked for soda refills, they never arrived. This was particularly surprising since we visited mid-afternoon and the restaurant wasn't busy. Overall, I'd give Not Your Average Joe's 3.5 stars out of 5. While I appreciated the gluten-free options and enjoyed the food, the value and service didn't quite live up to my expectations. Perhaps with some adjustments, I'd consider returning and bumping up my rating.

Danielle Rogg Guillermo

Delicious pizza, excellent service! Best gluten free pizza I’ve had state side! The gluten free crust was soft and bready. I called in my order and they reassured me they are careful about cross contamination and cross contact. My non GF family members raved about their pizza as well. A win for everyone!

Kimball Family

Honestly, it's my favorite place for dinner on the Cape! Seriously, fantastic Italian food with so many gluten-free options! My daughter and I eat here often and never get sick. Our faves include the gluten-free meatballs and gluten-free pasta with white clam sauce. Their drinks are always good, and the service is fabulous. 5 stars all around ✨️ my only hope is they decide to add gluten-free veal parm to the menu one day 😋

Jacqueline Kalina

We’ve worked with Mike’s Pizza two years in a row now to cater our soccer tournament’s pizza party—over 300 people and two dinner seatings each time—and they absolutely knocked it out of the park both years! 🎉 From start to finish, everything was super easy. The team at Mike’s Pizza is so kind and accommodating, the food is delicious (people were raving about it!), and they even had great gluten-free options, which helped us make sure everyone was included. They were right on time with delivery, super organized, and honestly made what could have been a really stressful event feel smooth and fun. We truly couldn’t have pulled it off without them. Amazing staff, amazing service, and we’re already looking forward to working with Mike’s Pizza again next year. Highly recommend them for any large event—or even just a night when you’re craving awesome pizza!

Dan Gallagher

Reasonably priced and tasty pizza. In addition, they make a very good gluten free pizza and ensure preparation is separate from flour pizza production.

Meghan Weston

The food is always good! They have a smaller menu but everything is delicious. They have the BEST gluten free pizza I've ever eaten! We started off with the brussel sprouts appetizer, it was perfectly crunchy with a delicious semi sweet sauce. And then ended with a classic Cesar Salad that had the perfect ratio of dressing to crisp lettuce and a gluten free margarita pizza (and added a side of hot honey).

Robert Padgett

This was take-out. From order to front door was 20 minutes. Delicious, but know that the gluten free option is only available with the small pizza.