Top 5 Gluten-Free Spots to Explore on Shelter Island

Shelter Island Slice

3 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA
LunchDinnerPizzaDeliveryTake AwayOutdoor SeatingKid Friendly
This spot caters thoughtfully to gluten-free diners with its gluten-free cauliflower pizza, ensuring a safe and delicious option. The relaxed and friendly atmosphere with indoor and outdoor seating creates a welcoming space where those with gluten sensitivities can enjoy specialty slices like Sausage and Broccoli Rabe without worry. The team's careful precautions for gluten allergies enhance the overall experience, making it a standout choice for gluten-free pizza lovers.
Menu
View menu

The Eccentric Bagel

25 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA
BreakfastBakeryCafeDeliveryTake AwayBread ItemsDesserts
This cozy spot offers a fresh, simple menu focused on gluten-free options, making it a standout for those seeking delicious alternatives. The gluten-free hummus and veggie wrap is fantastic, perfectly complementing the inviting atmosphere and cool, well-designed decor. Its reputation for the best bagels on the entire East End extends to accommodating gluten-free diners, creating a welcoming oasis for all.
Menu
View menu

Opties and Dinghies

87 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA
LunchDinnerDeliveryTake AwayOutdoor SeatingKid FriendlyRestaurant
This spot is an incredible place for gluten-free eating, offering a chill atmosphere that invites relaxation. Every dish is cooked to perfection, ensuring that gluten-free diners enjoy authentic flavors without compromise. The amazing gelato also caters thoughtfully to gluten-free needs, making it a standout choice for those seeking genuine, safe options in a welcoming setting.
Menu
View menu

Maria's Kitchen

55 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA
BreakfastLunchDinnerDeliveryTake AwayOutdoor SeatingKid FriendlyRestaurant
Gluten-free options are thoughtfully integrated into the extensive menu, allowing guests to enjoy authentic Spanish and Tex-Mex flavors without compromise. The charming outdoor garden dining area, surrounded by fresh herbs, provides a serene and inviting atmosphere that enhances the dining experience for those seeking safe and flavorful gluten-free meals.
Menu
View menu

Vine Street Café

41 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA
DinnerAmericanDeliveryTake AwayOutdoor SeatingBarRestaurant
This dining spot offers a warm, inviting atmosphere with both indoor and outdoor seating that creates a cozy yet energetic vibe, perfect for those seeking gluten free culinary delights. Guests highlight the amazing gluten free scallop dish and the terrific prawns over asparagus, showcasing a thoughtful menu that caters to gluten free preferences without compromising flavor. The unique tuna tacos add an adventurous touch, making this a standout destination for gluten free dining experiences.
Menu
View menu

© 2025 Atly - Your Local Guide to Gluten-Free Dining