Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 places for herring and seafood to enjoy in New York City

Based on 678 Reviews
+675
User
User
User
Updated
01
Fish N' Dish image 1
Fish N' Dish image 2
Fish N' Dish image 3
View all

Fish N' Dish

🐟 Herring
🦞 Seafood
🐟 Fish
🐟 Salmon
More

State-of-the-art fish store with spotless cleanliness and modern design creates a fresh, odor-free atmosphere. Fish selection stands out for exceptional freshness and high quality, making it unique among similar stores.

People are saying

"The fish is always fresh and the store is spotless."

"They offer a great variety of tasty fish and dips."

"The seafood here is always super fresh and nicely cleaned."

Good to know

1

The store offers fresh fish daily, sourced from local fishermen.

2

Expect a variety of seafood options, including shellfish and seasonal catches.

3

Parking is available on-site, but it can fill up quickly during peak hours.

02
Freund's Fish Market image 1
Freund's Fish Market image 2
Freund's Fish Market image 3
View all
🐟 Herring
🦞 Seafood
🐟 Fish
🎌 Japanese Food
More

Seafood market with extensive fresh and frozen kosher fish selection and innovative sauces and spice blends. Atmosphere reflects pride in quality and family tradition, offering fast delivery across Brooklyn. Known for consistently fresh fish and standout sushi.

People are saying

"The seafood here is incredibly fresh and high quality."

Good to know

1

Freund's Fish Market offers a wide variety of fresh fish, sauces, and spice blends.

2

Free delivery is available across all of Brooklyn.

3

The market has a large selection of both fresh and frozen fish.

03
Tsar Caviar image 1
Tsar Caviar image 2
Tsar Caviar image 3
View all
🐟 Herring
🦞 Seafood
🏷️ Affordable
🍣 Caviar
More

Gourmet grocery store offers a cozy, sophisticated ambiance with a beautiful, elegant design. It features a large selection of premium caviar and related products at competitive prices. The atmosphere feels luxurious yet friendly, attracting those seeking high-quality specialty foods.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh and the caviar is exquisite."

"They have a great variety of fresh seafood and caviar."

"The seafood is always fresh and tastes amazing."

Good to know

1

The selection of caviar is unmatched with excellent seafood products.

2

Sarcaviar prioritizes ethical sourcing practices for their caviar.

3

There are nice discounts on red and black caviar.

04
D Roti Hut image 1
D Roti Hut image 2
D Roti Hut image 3
View all
🐟 Herring
🦞 Seafood
🎯 Authentic
🥘 Food
More

Caribbean restaurant offers a casual dining space with cleanliness and generous seating. Soca music and an arcade create a lively, chill vibe. The aroma of authentic dishes draws a diverse crowd, highlighting budget-friendly, flavorful cuisine.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so flavorful and delicious."

"The shrimp doubles here are really delicious."

"The shrimp and salt fish taste like they’re made with love."

Good to know

1

On busy days, you might have to wait 10-15 minutes for a table.

2

The pricing is very reasonable for the food being served.

3

Items may get bought out for the day, so arrive early.

05
Aquavit image 1
Aquavit image 2
Aquavit image 3
View all
🐟 Herring
🦞 Seafood
💎 Classy
🍽️ Lunch Spot
More

Scandinavian restaurant blends elegant decor with a casual vibe and an open kitchen. Herring sampler delivers juicy, flavorful bites alongside fresh seafood. Dishes highlight impeccable freshness and smoky, sea salt textures for a true Nordic taste.

People are saying

"The seafood here is impeccably fresh and cooked to perfection."

"The seafood is fresh, perfectly cooked, and balanced."

"I loved the herring amuses and tartare bites."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended well in advance due to high demand.

2

The ice cream cocktail tasting experience is available only in August.

3

Christmas Dinner requires a reservation and can be quite expensive.

06
Russ & Daughters Cafe image 1
Russ & Daughters Cafe image 2
Russ & Daughters Cafe image 3
View all
🦞 Seafood
🐟 Herring
🥞 Brunch
📻 Vintage
More

Classic bagel and lox shine in a warm, retro diner setting with homey atmosphere and classy servers. Spiced pickled herring offers a savory depth that pairs well with homemade bagels and latkes. Smoked fish brings a fresh, wholly smoked taste, making it a top spot for unique seafood flavors.

People are saying

"The smoked fish here is silky, perfectly sliced, and worth the legacy."

"The smoked fish and bagels here are top notch and varied."

"The pickled herring trio was so tasty, my favorite dish."

Good to know

1

Making a reservation is necessary to avoid a wait of over an hour.

2

Expect to wait on busy weekend mornings; arrive early to get on the list.

3

No reservations are accepted, so expect long waits on weekends.

07
BunNan image 1
BunNan image 2
BunNan image 3
View all
🐟 Herring
🦞 Seafood
🥘 Food
🥪 Sandwich
More

Caribbean restaurant with modern decor and a warm, welcoming vibe that reflects Haitian charm. Outdoor seating includes a hidden backyard area offering fresh air and a relaxed setting. Music features lively mixtapes, creating an inviting atmosphere where friendly people gather.

People are saying

"The food is packed with bold, authentic flavors."

"Jimmy made us feel welcome and cared for."

"The Seafood here is amazing, thanks to the great hosts."

Good to know

1

They close at 8pm on Sundays.

2

Happy hour runs with special deals on food and drinks.

3

Game nights occur every Friday, attracting a lively crowd.

08
Russ & Daughters image 1
Russ & Daughters image 2
Russ & Daughters image 3
View all
🦞 Seafood
🐟 Herring
🥯 Bagel With Lox
🐟 Salmon
More

Small, narrow shop with an old school vibe and no indoor seating. Offers flavorful curry and mustard dill herring alongside creamy whitefish salad. Features classic Jewish smoked fish like sturgeon and sable on bagels with cream cheese.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh, especially the smoked fish."

"I loved how fresh the smoked fish and bagels were."

"Everyone talks about their amazing smoked fish and bagels."

Good to know

1

You must take a number when you first enter to be served.

2

There is no dine-in option; it's takeout only.

3

Expect long wait times, often over an hour, especially after 10am.

09
Benz's Food Products image 1
Benz's Food Products image 2
Benz's Food Products image 3
View all
🦞 Seafood
🐟 Herring
🕍 Kosher
🐟 Fish
More

Shop offers fresh herring that pairs perfectly with kichel and pickles, creating a delightful spread. Seafood lovers enjoy fresh salmon and a variety of fish every Friday at reasonable prices. The store's kosher gourmet foods and warm atmosphere make it a top choice for unique finds.

People are saying

"Their fresh and smoked fish always taste great and cost less."

"I found their seafood selection to be wide and the prices great."

"They have a huge choice of top-quality fish and specialty foods."

Good to know

1

Everything in the store is kosher, ensuring compliance with dietary laws.

2

The store has a large selection of unique kosher products not found elsewhere.

3

Expect a wide variety of fish, dairy, and gourmet items.

10
Zum Stammtisch image 1
Zum Stammtisch image 2
Zum Stammtisch image 3
View all
🦞 Seafood
🐟 Herring
🎯 Authentic
🥨 Pretzels
More

Dark wood and traditional Bavarian decor create a strong German vibe. The German herring salad offers bold, tangy flavors that divide opinions. Seafood lovers enjoy the fried shrimp special and fresh salmon options.

People are saying

"I love the authentic German food and cozy vibe."

"Parking around here is always tough to find."

"The bar is a great spot to relax and enjoy."

Good to know

1

Make sure to make a reservation during the holidays.

2

Goulash is only available on Tuesdays.

3

The prime rib is only available twice a week.