Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots for Italian food to Enjoy in Lenox Hill, New York City

Based on 788 Reviews
+785
User
User
User
Updated
01
Donna Margherita image 1
Donna Margherita image 2
Donna Margherita image 3
View all
🇮🇹 Italian Food
🎯 Authentic
🍝 Linguine
🧀 Eggplant Parmigiana
More

Space feels like a slice of Naples with wood-fired oven and imported decor. Cozy atmosphere suits small groups and intimate talks. Authentic Italian dishes like spaghetti and meatballs and rich lasagna impress every time.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the pizza, is outstanding and authentic."

"The Italian food here tastes truly authentic and amazing."

"It feels like a real Italian home with authentic vibes."

Good to know

1

Reservations are advisable, especially during weekends and special events.

2

Credit card payments incur an additional charge, so consider cash for convenience.

3

Every dish is handcrafted in-house, ensuring freshness and authenticity.

02
da Adriano image 1
da Adriano image 2
da Adriano image 3
View all
🇮🇹 Italian Food
🎯 Authentic
🍅 Gazpacho
🛋️ Cozy
More

Tiny Italian spot offers homemade pasta and authentic dishes like spaghetti cacio e pepe. Cozy vibe with outdoor bistro seating and warm decor. Enjoy a notable Aperol Spritz alongside fresh, traditional meals.

People are saying

"This Italian food spot is so cozy and intimate."

"I love how cozy and truly authentic the Italian food is here."

"The Italian music and vibe make me feel right at home."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially during peak hours.

2

The average cost per person is $60 for a meal with wine and dessert.

3

The panini sandwich costs $20, offering a casual dining option.

03
Bigoi Venezia image 1
Bigoi Venezia image 2
Bigoi Venezia image 3
View all
🇮🇹 Italian Food
🤙 Casual
🍝 Spaghetti
🏷️ Affordable
More

Small, cozy spot offers fresh handmade pasta with unique Venetian flavors at extremely fair prices. Warm kitchen vibe and limited bar seating create a casual, quick experience perfect for takeout or a brief sit-down. Clean and comfortable setting enhances the charm.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the pasta, is so fresh and delicious."

"The pasta tastes just like real Italian homemade pasta."

"The food is fresh and tastes better than most Italian places."

Good to know

1

The fast pasta is ready in 5 minutes.

2

The prices are cheap, around $15 per person.

3

The portion size is very good for what you pay, easily enough for two portions.

04
La Pizza Italia 🇮🇹 image 1
La Pizza Italia 🇮🇹 image 2
La Pizza Italia 🇮🇹 image 3
View all
🇮🇹 Italian Food
🍕 Pizza Slices
🏷️ Affordable
🍕 Pizza
More

Bright, clean space with cozy atmosphere and loud music creates a lively vibe. Enjoy burrata basil pizza and tasty rigatoni vodka with great deals. Perfect for casual dining and quick slices in a distinctly New York setting.

People are saying

"I love the fresh pasta and great deals."

"I loved the buy one get one free pasta deal!"

"The burrata basil pizza tastes amazing and costs less."

Good to know

1

The pizzeria offers a buy one get one free deal on the pasta special.

2

The restaurant is affordable.

3

The new pizza shop has good prices.

05
Figo Il Gelato Italiano image 1
Figo Il Gelato Italiano image 2
Figo Il Gelato Italiano image 3
View all
🇮🇹 Italian Food
🍨 Gelato
🍦 Ice Cream
🌰 Pistachio
More

Bright, clean space serves authentic Italian gelato with creamy textures and unique flavors like pistachio. Cozy, relaxed atmosphere offers a warm, welcoming vibe reminiscent of Tuscany. Affogato and fresh Italian pastries like chocolate chip cannoli complete the rich experience.

People are saying

"I think this place has the best gelato around."

"The affogato and cannoli always hit the spot."

"I loved the fresh tiramisu and the best affogato."

Good to know

1

One scoop costs $6.50 after tax and tip, and two scoops cost $8.50.

2

Expect to pay around $10.25 for two scoops after a tip.

3

Credit cards are accepted for payment.

06
Peng's Noodle Folk image 1
Peng's Noodle Folk image 2
Peng's Noodle Folk image 3
View all
🇮🇹 Italian Food
🛋️ Cozy
💎 Hidden Gems
🎌 Japanese Food
More

Small space with dim lighting and gears-and-lights sculptures creates a cozy, elegant vibe. Atmosphere feels more like a takeout spot but offers relaxed seating and quiet comfort. Popular for northern Chinese noodles and has a steady flow of takeout orders.

People are saying

"I love the cozy vibe and tasty handmade noodles."

"The portions are big and filling."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is currently not operational due to relocation.

2

The new location on 72nd is not opened yet.

3

The prices are affordable, around €30 per person.

07
Sultan Mediterranean Cuisine image 1
Sultan Mediterranean Cuisine image 2
Sultan Mediterranean Cuisine image 3
View all
🇮🇹 Italian Food
🍽️ Lunch Spot
🛋️ Cozy
🎯 Authentic
More

Massive interior with white tablecloths and small tea lights creates an elegant, calming atmosphere. Faint Turkish music plays softly, adding to the cozy and inviting vibe. Outdoor terrace and friendly, attentive staff enhance the polished, neighborhood feel.

People are saying

"The food tastes authentic and delicious."

"I highly recommend this place to everyone."

"I will definitely come back again soon."

Good to know

1

Come for Iskender Kebap at noon.

2

On weekdays, they have great lunch deals.

3

Sultan Mediterranean restaurant has good happy hour prices and menu.

08
Shaken Not Stirred image 1
Shaken Not Stirred image 2
Shaken Not Stirred image 3
View all
🇮🇹 Italian Food
🍸 Mixology
💕 Romantic
🛋️ Cozy
More

Cocktail bar shines with exceptional drinks and a warm, vibrant atmosphere. Italian food features salami and ricotta toasts and pasta, paired with unique sides like kimchi fries. Chic, eclectic decor blends classic and modern styles, perfect for intimate chats or lively celebrations.

People are saying

"I love the cocktails and chill vibe here."

"I always love the ricotta and salami toasts."

"The kimchi fries and pasta are so tasty."

Good to know

1

Happy hour prices include cocktails off the menu.

2

There is no happy hour on Sundays.

3

Making a reservation is recommended.

09
Sea Salt NYC image 1
Sea Salt NYC image 2
Sea Salt NYC image 3
View all
🇮🇹 Italian Food
🐙 Grilled Octopus
🛋️ Cozy
🍽️ Lunch Spot
More

Mediterranean restaurant shines with fresh seafood pasta and grilled octopus that highlight Italian flavors. Elegant interior and chic décor create a lively vibe, especially near the bar. Guests savor a spectacular Greek wine selection that complements standout dishes perfectly.

People are saying

"The food is fantastic and the vibe is great."

"The Italian food here is amazing, especially the pasta."

"The seafood pasta and scallops were delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for large tables on weekends.

2

Happy hour runs from 3 PM to 6 PM on Fridays with vegan options available.

3

The venue can accommodate large parties, but it's best to reserve in advance.

10
Marlow East image 1
Marlow East image 2
Marlow East image 3
View all
🇮🇹 Italian Food
🛋️ Cozy
💎 Classy
🍅 Gazpacho
More

Floor-to-ceiling glass windows create an upscale vibe while fresh floral arrangements add warmth. Pasta dishes like corn crab agnolotti showcase unique sweet corn flavors despite some thick dough. Outdoor seating offers a relaxed dining option with great music enhancing the chill energy.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is amazing, especially the lobster spaghetti."

"I loved the sweet corn pasta dishes."

"The lobster spaghetti was a big letdown."

Good to know

1

Getting a reservation at Marlow East is very difficult.

2

The menu is small but thoughtfully crafted with organic ingredients.

3

Expect high prices, averaging around $100 per person.