Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in New York

Rustic Lasagna

Made for those who prefer their lasagna served in a space that feels unpretentious and grounded.

Based on 530 Opinions
+527
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Celeste image 1
Celeste image 2
Celeste image 3
View all
Italian restaurant

Cozy spot with wood-fired ovens offers a creamy bรฉchamel lasagna rich in mushroom flavors. Rustic dรฉcor and warm lighting create a homey vibe that feels like an Italian grandmother's kitchen. Friendly, lively atmosphere pairs well with classic Italian movies and cocktails.

Lasagna features four types of mushrooms and a creamy bรฉchamel sauce or a rich Bolognese option. Presentation is neat and the flavors stand out clearly.

Wood-fired ovens create pizzas with a smoky wood flavor. Warm lighting and rustic dรฉcor give the place a homey, Italian grandmother vibe. The atmosphere feels authentic and unrefined.

People are saying

"The homemade Italian food, especially the pasta, tastes so fresh."

"I thought the lasagna was the best I ever had."

"It's so rustic and homey, like an Italian grandmother's kitchen."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is cash only, so it's important to bring cash.

2

Celeste is cash only, so you need to hit an ATM before visiting.

3

The restaurant week offer runs until Feb 9 according to the menu.

02
il Gigante image 1
Italian restaurant

Rustic interiors create an elegantly cozy atmosphere with great music enhancing the vibe. Neighborhood warmth blends with fine dining touches, attracting locals and visitors alike. Homemade pasta and carafes of wine complement the inviting, unpretentious setting.

Exceptional lasagna stands out with refined comfort and fresh flavors. It pairs well with other delicate pastas and rich dishes like meatballs and burrata.

Interiors show an elegantly rustic style with timeless character. Rustic bread is served but tastes ordinary.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is authentic and fantastic."

"I tried their lasagna and found it very good."

"The interiors are elegantly rustic and have character."

Good to know

1

The restaurant opened just a week ago, so expect some growing pains.

2

The menu includes vegan options for those with dietary restrictions.

3

Prices are reasonable compared to other Italian restaurants in the area.

03
Sicily Osteria image 1
Italian restaurant

Modern Italian restaurant offers massive space with stylish decor and multiple dining areas including an outdoor patio and glass roof terrace. Atmosphere feels inviting and evokes Amalfi coast vibes with a friendly, relaxed energy. Guests enjoy beautiful outdoor seating and a setting that balances elegance with comfort.

Italian sausage lasagna stands out with its rich flavor and significant improvement over regular versions. The dish consistently earns high praise for being delicious and outstanding.

Rustic charm fills the space with vintage green walls and exposed brick that recall a small Sicilian village. The decor and atmosphere feel welcoming and cozy, like a traditional Sicilian tavern.

People are saying

"The homemade pasta and sauces in this Italian food are rich and flavorful."

"I enjoyed the lasagna; it was quite good."

"The rustic decor here feels warm, authentic, and reminiscent of a Sicilian village."

Good to know

1

Securing a reservation is highly recommended due to the restaurant's popularity.

2

Happy hour is only available on the bar side of the restaurant.

3

The restaurant week lunch menu offers 3 courses for $30 on Sunday afternoons.

04
Rubirosa image 1
Pizza restaurant

Narrow space with a NYC vibe and tight seating creates an intimate but sometimes cramped atmosphere. Calm music and great air conditioning balance the energy, making it comfortable despite the crowd. Frequent door traffic can cause temperature shifts, adding to the dynamic environment.

Huge portions come with the lasagna for two, featuring a sweet tomato flavor that does not overpower. It stands out as one of the best lasagnas experienced here.

Victorian style gives the place a rustic look from outside. Inside, the atmosphere feels cozy and comfortable with a rustic vibe. Homemade Italian wedding soup comes with fresh, flavorful broth and rustic bread.

People are saying

"The pizza here is thin-crust perfection with a flavorful, crispy crust."

"I loved their thin crust pizza, it was so crispy and chewy."

"The lasagna's layers were so well-defined and cheesy."

Good to know

1

Reservations should be made 1 or 2 days in advance.

2

The usual wait is 45-60 minutes, not 90+ minutes.

3

You need to be punctual as they mean it when they say you have ten minutes to get there after the text.

05
Morandi image 1
Italian restaurant

Rustic interior with heated outdoor patio creates a warm, bustling atmosphere that feels lively and packed. Seating is somewhat cramped, and noise levels rise as sound bounces off surfaces. Staff are notably kind, adding to the charming vibe of the space.

Rich layers of bolognese sauce, cheese, and bรฉchamel define the lasagna here. The Sunday evening special offers a unique take, complementing other dishes like pumpkin ravioli.

Rustic and charming interior creates a warm, cozy vibe like a local Italian family spot. The tavern-style design adds a relaxed, authentic feel that transports you away from the city bustle.

People are saying

"William gave great food recommendations."

"The Italian food here feels like family, thanks to Olivia's hospitality."

"The lasagna here is the lasagna of my dreams."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly advisable, especially during busy times.

2

The restaurant gets busy during Happy Hours and on weekends.

3

Prices are on the higher side, with some dishes being overpriced.

06
Tucci New York City image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant with beautiful, detailed decor and stunning plants creates a cozy atmosphere. Bar area feels crammed, and occasional loud noises affect the vibe. Drinks and food offer exceptional quality, enhancing the overall experience.

Lasagna stands out with its kimchi twist and classic al forno style. Every bite shows chef's skill and dedication to quality.

Rustic decor creates a cozy, natural vibe blending urban chic with nature's calm. The ambiance highlights natural flavors and suits special occasions well.

People are saying

"The food here is simple, well-prepared, and delicious."

"The food here is tremendous, especially the pastas and chicken parm."

"The Rustic food here is amazing, truly exceeding expectations."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to high demand and overbooking issues.

2

Expect long wait times even with a reservation, especially during dinner service.

3

Prices are high, with meals averaging around $100 per person.

07
Maestro Pasta image 1
Italian restaurant

Open kitchen with chefs making fresh pasta creates an engaging setting. Swings replace chairs at tables, adding a unique and playful touch. Live music enhances a cozy, authentic Italian atmosphere with handmade pasta, swing seating, live music, and an open kitchen.

Lasagna features fresh, high-quality ingredients with options like the Pesto Lasagna for vegetarians. Pasta dishes show a clear commitment to quality and flavor.

Soft lighting and rustic decor create a warm, intimate vibe. Creative elements like copper pipe lighting and swinging chairs add a unique touch to the family-friendly atmosphere.

People are saying

"The pasta here is handmade and amazingly delicious."

"I thought the lasagna here was the best in New York."

"The rustic ambiance feels like a warm welcome from new friends."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm with discounted wines before 7pm.

2

Live music is available every Thursday night.

3

Reservations are recommended to secure a table, especially on weekends.

08
Emporio image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers cozy decor with a backyard seating area featuring natural light from a glass panel roof. Atmosphere is chic and lively, often filled with great music that enhances the vibrant energy. Space accommodates larger groups comfortably, making it suitable for social gatherings.

Lamb takes center stage in the lasagna, which sometimes resembles a lamb pie more than a traditional dish. Opinions vary, with some finding the lamb lasagna a highlight and others less impressed.

Natural light fills the back room through a glass panel roof, creating a bright and airy space. The wood oven bakes pizzas fresh, adding to the rustic atmosphere with cozy decor and dim lighting.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is outstanding, with thoughtfully crafted dishes."

"The rustic food here is delicious, especially the pizza and pasta."

"I really enjoyed the great lasagna here."

Good to know

1

A reservation is definitely needed for dinner.

2

Without a reservation, it is very difficult to get a place on the weekend.

3

Finding parking can be difficult sometimes in New York.

09
Convivium Osteria image 1
Italian restaurant

Elegant Italian restaurant with a rustic aesthetic and dim lighting creates a romantic, cozy atmosphere. Intimate spaces include a private wine cellar that adds charm and depth to the setting. Noise levels can vary, sometimes rising due to loud music, affecting conversation comfort.

Lasagna comes as a solid choice with gluten free fettuccini available alongside it. It ranks among several very good dishes like cured meat and ravioli.

Rustic charm shines through with a cozy atmosphere and dim lighting that creates a warm, inviting space. The setting feels like a classic Italian dining experience with a simple, natural aesthetic.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

"It's a cozy spot with a rustic Italian vibe."

"I thought the lasagna was acceptable."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to the restaurant's small size and high demand.

2

The Valentine's pre-fixe menu costs $80 per person, not listed online.

3

Expect inflated prices compared to the online menu.

Discover more

New York, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...