Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots for peanut butter and jelly to Enjoy in New York City

Based on 776 Reviews
+773
User
User
User
Updated
01
da Toscano image 1
da Toscano image 2
da Toscano image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🍝 Pappardelle
🍝 Orecchiette
🛋️ Cozy
More

Italian spot shines with exceptional pasta and cozy atmosphere featuring dim lighting and a wine bottle wall. Try the unique PB&J Bombolone with foie gras filling blending peanut butter and jelly for a bold twist. Perfect for intimate dinners and adventurous eaters.

People are saying

"I always find the pasta here absolutely amazing."

"The tiramisu sundae is the best dessert here."

"The Peanut Butter And Jelly bombolone was unforgettable."

Good to know

1

Make a reservation before visiting to ensure a table.

2

The Porchetta pop-up is available at lunchtime on Thursday, Friday, and Saturday.

3

The restaurant has a 90-minute limit for meals, which is mentioned in the small print on their website.

02
Daytime image 1
Daytime image 2
Daytime image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🛋️ Cozy
🥐 Croissant
🍳 Breakfast
More

Cozy cafe on a quiet side street offers limited seating with sunlit windows filled with plants. The atmosphere is chill and neighborly, though music can be loud for the small space. Frequent crowds form on weekday mornings, creating a lively but tight environment.

People are saying

"I love the chill vibe and great coffee here."

"The sandwiches here are always tasty and fresh."

Good to know

1

Parking in the area is generally a nightmare.

2

The line is generally long and moves slowly.

3

The seating is insufficient at the location.

03
Li-Lac Chocolates (Hudson Yards) image 1
Li-Lac Chocolates (Hudson Yards) image 2
Li-Lac Chocolates (Hudson Yards) image 3
View all

Li-Lac Chocolates (Hudson Yards)

🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🍫 Chocolate
🍯 Caramel
🍬 Candy
More

Chocolate shop offers an amazing variety of all-natural chocolates with no sugar or artificial sweeteners. Atmosphere feels personal and engaging, with knowledgeable staff guiding through chocolate-making and sampling. Experience combines creative selections and a sense of pride in craftsmanship.

Good to know

1

Sampling chocolates is encouraged before making a purchase.

2

The store offers a wide variety of handmade chocolates.

3

Li-Lac Chocolates is known for its high-quality, all-natural ingredients.

04
Park Cafe image 1
Park Cafe image 2
Park Cafe image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
Cafe
🏷️ Affordable
🌭 Sausage
More

Small, cozy space with well-lit interior and comfortable seating for chatting or working. Atmosphere feels friendly and nostalgic, enhanced by homemade treats and occasional free samples. Quiet vibe invites relaxed visits without rushing.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh and delicious."

"I love the cozy vibe and friendly owner here."

"The prices here are really affordable and fair."

Good to know

1

The cafe offers coffee, tea, breakfast, lunch, and sweets.

2

Pricing is very affordable.

3

The shop does not have much space to sit in.

05
Bear Donut image 1
Bear Donut image 2
Bear Donut image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🍞 Brioche
🍰 Tiramisu
🍨 Desserts
More

Small shop serves colorful mochi donuts with a standout PB&J brioche base that stays moist and flavorful. Asian-inspired soft serve adds a trendy twist in a cute, upbeat space. Limited seating suits quick visits in a warm, homemade vibe.

People are saying

"The chewy donuts have fun, tasty flavors."

"I can't get enough of the peanut butter and jelly donut."

"The limited edition peanut butter and jelly donut really hit the spot."

Good to know

1

The breakfast waffle donut is only available between 8AM - 2PM.

2

Mochi donuts cost $3.75 and larger donuts cost $5.

3

Bear Donut does not have seating inside.

06
787 Coffee image 1
787 Coffee image 2
787 Coffee image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
😎 Chill
🛋️ Cozy
Latte
More

Coffee shop offers natural light, plants, and varied seating for working or relaxing. Atmosphere combines welcoming decor with a curated playlist and occasional acoustic acts. Patrons engage with unique touches like writing gratitude notes on coffee filters, creating a distinct community vibe.

People are saying

"I love the cozy vibe and relaxing atmosphere here."

"Their coffee flavors like horchata and dulce de leche are amazing."

"Xavier always makes the place feel welcoming and fun."

Good to know

1

The coffee shop closes at 7PM.

2

Expect live music events regularly throughout the month.

3

Discounts are available for healthcare workers.

07
Joey Roses image 1
Joey Roses image 2
Joey Roses image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
😎 Cool
🏘️ Local Spot
💎 Hidden Gems
More

Small sandwich shop with retro decor and loud dubstep music creates a lively vibe. Peanut butter and jelly sandwiches like The Fatboy offer rich, balanced flavors. Free arcade games and a personal movie room make it a unique hangout spot.

People are saying

"The place has a cool vibe and great prices."

"I love how fresh and affordable the sandwiches taste."

"The sandwiches here are the best with fresh bread."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm with great drink specials.

2

Joey Roses offers a "buy 2 get 1 free" sandwich deal during happy hour.

3

Expect to wait over an hour for your sandwich during peak hours.

08
Elsa image 1
Elsa image 2
Elsa image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
💕 Romantic
🍸 Cocktail Bar
🚽 Bathroom
More

Bar blends Art Deco and Star Wars design with custom glass lighting. Loud reggaeton music fills the main room, but a quiet backyard patio offers calm. Small bites include peanut butter and jelly, olives, and cheese boards, making snacks solid and tasty.

People are saying

"I love the creative cocktails and chill vibe here."

"I was annoyed by the surprise gratuity on my bill."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs Tuesday to Friday from 5-7 PM with select cocktails priced at $6-$8.

2

The bar can accommodate parties of two or four comfortably.

3

The venue adds gratuity for groups over six, even with separate tabs.

09
Doughnut Plant image 1
Doughnut Plant image 2
Doughnut Plant image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🍩 Donuts
🍰 Cake
🍞 Sourdough
More

Tiny shop offers a colorful doughnut display with a cozy, modern vibe and loud music. Seating is limited but casual, including sidewalk spots. Peanut butter and jelly doughnut shines with a rich filling and yeast base, paired with chocolate Valrhona for extra flavor.

People are saying

"I love the tasty donuts and changing flavors."

"The crème brûlée donut is my top pick."

"The peanut butter and jelly donut was our go-to choice."

Good to know

1

Their new store hours are 8am to 4pm.

2

You should go early because they sell out fairly fast.

3

A single donut at The Donut Plant costs around $4.50+.

10
375° Chicken 'n Fries image 1
375° Chicken 'n Fries image 2
375° Chicken 'n Fries image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🥘 Food
🍟 Fast Food
🍄 Truffles
More

Small, brightly lit spot offers bold peanut butter & jelly mixes like PB&J Chick 'n Pop. Cramped dining with high-top tables suits quick meals. Clean, inviting vibe with wall art creates a chill atmosphere for fast food lovers.

People are saying

"The food tastes great despite the small dining area."

"I love the bold flavors and crispy fries here."

"I always recommend this place for tasty chicken."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is halal and a certificate is posted on the notice board inside.

2

Make sure you're hungry, it's a large portion.

3

There isn’t a lot of seating available.