Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots where pumpernickel meets sourdough in New York City

Based on 764 Reviews
+761
User
User
User
Updated
01
HAGS image 1
HAGS image 2
HAGS image 3
View all
🍞 Sourdough
🍞 Pumpernickel Bread
🍷 Fine Dining
Unique
More

Small space with intimate seating and warm 70's/80's lounge vibe creates a cozy, inclusive atmosphere. Energy stays welcoming and non-pretentious, blending fine dining with accessibility. Attention to detail shows in thoughtful dishware and creative, inventive cuisine.

People are saying

"The food was amazing and full of surprises."

"The vibe is relaxed, friendly, and truly inclusive."

"The brunch is amazing and easy on the wallet."

Good to know

1

The brunch operates on a sliding scale, allowing guests to pay what they can.

2

The tasting menu changes seasonally, offering new dishes throughout the year.

3

Seatings for tastings start simultaneously, serving all tables the same course.

02
Northside Bakery image 1
Northside Bakery image 2
Northside Bakery image 3
View all
🍞 Pumpernickel Bread
🍞 Sourdough
🥐 Pastry
🥐 Bakery
More

Small, clean bakery offers fresh Eastern European breads and Polish-style foods in a cozy, quiet setting. Limited seating encourages a grab-and-go experience with a steady line of customers. The atmosphere feels like a longstanding neighborhood institution rather than a trendy spot.

People are saying

"The sourdough here is crusty and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Expect 10-15 minute wait times during peak hours.

2

The bakery offers holiday specials throughout the year.

3

Prices for baked goods can be higher than average.

03
Elbow Bread image 1
Elbow Bread image 2
Elbow Bread image 3
View all
🍞 Sourdough
🍞 Pumpernickel Bread
🥟 Potato Knish
🧁 Danish
More

Small bakery with rustic wooden accents and bright, airy lighting creates a cozy, friendly atmosphere. No seating inside encourages a grab-and-go experience amid a bustling vibe. Aromas of fresh bread and pastries fill the space, adding to its charm.

People are saying

"I love their unique breads and tasty pastries."

"The sourdough bread has a distinct flavor and character."

"The prices felt high, but I want to come back."

Good to know

1

A double pretzel costs $15, while a single pretzel usually costs $7.

2

Expect no line on Friday mornings around 9:45am.

3

The bakery does not start serving pretzels until later in the day.

04
Orwashers Bakery image 1
Orwashers Bakery image 2
Orwashers Bakery image 3
View all
🍞 Sourdough
🍞 Pumpernickel Bread
🏘️ Local Spot
🥐 Bakery
More

Artisanal bakery offers a cozy atmosphere with fresh bread aromas and outdoor seating. Pumpernickel shines with its rich flavor in bread and raisin forms, while sourdough impresses with fresh, well-made texture. Wide variety includes bagels and croissants.

People are saying

"I found the sourdough here to be one of the best I had."

"I always go for their sourdough bread."

"Their sourdough and cinnamon raisin bread are the best I've had."

Good to know

1

If you have an online pick-up order, have your confirmation email ready.

2

Customers should expect to wait a long time for their drinks.

3

There is no sitting area in the bakery; it's just take out.

05
Bagelworks image 1
Bagelworks image 2
Bagelworks image 3
View all
🍞 Pumpernickel Bread
🍞 Sourdough
🥯 Everything Bagel
🍳 Breakfast
More

Small, old school New York-style bagel shop with visible bagel boiling and baking behind the counter creates an authentic, energetic vibe. Inside feels cramped and loud, while spacious outdoor seating offers a more relaxed option. The atmosphere captures a hectic NYC bagel shop experience with a gritty, local feel.

People are saying

"The bagels are fresh, tasty, and come in many flavors."

"The coffee tastes good and hits the spot."

"The muffins are delicious with great flavors."

Good to know

1

Consider ordering ahead to avoid long lines on weekends.

2

They have a $5 minimum for credit card, so bring cash or plan to order a few bagels.

3

Expect to wait during weekend mornings.

06
Galaxy Diner image 1
Galaxy Diner image 2
Galaxy Diner image 3
View all
🍞 Pumpernickel Bread
🍞 Sourdough
🍟 Diner
🍳 Breakfast
More

Galaxy-themed ceiling artwork creates a memorable atmosphere in a space that blends cozy diner vibes with a hip, clean decor. The place offers a full bar and outdoor seating, attracting a family-friendly crowd with lively energy and good music.

People are saying

"I loved the cozy vibe and tasty food here."

"The prices here are fair and affordable."

"I highly recommend this place to others."

Good to know

1

The diner is open 24 hours for all meals.

2

This place fills up fast in the mornings, so arrive early.

3

Breakfast is served all day, making it a great option anytime.

07
Court Street Bagels image 1
Court Street Bagels image 2
Court Street Bagels image 3
View all
🍞 Sourdough
🍞 Pumpernickel Bread
🐟 Salmon
🥯 Bagels
More

Bagel shop buzzes with crowded seating and a cash-only policy. Sourdough bagels offer a distinct tang and chewy bite, while pumpernickel shines as a popular takeaway option. Loud music and a modern vibe contrast with local Brooklyn roots.

People are saying

"The bagels here are fresh, tasty, and worth it."

"I find the cash-only policy frustrating and outdated."

"The pumpernickel bread here is chewy and flavorful."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is cash only; bring cash or use the ATM inside.

2

You should show up early as this is a hot spot on weekend mornings.

3

You MUST check your order before you leave and open up each item.

08
Tompkins Square Bagels | Union Square Bagel Shop image 1
Tompkins Square Bagels | Union Square Bagel Shop image 2
Tompkins Square Bagels | Union Square Bagel Shop image 3
View all
🍞 Sourdough
🍞 Pumpernickel Bread
🥛 Dairy Free
🌱 Vegan Friendly
More

Small bagel shop buzzes with lively atmosphere and fast lines. Pumpernickel bagels offer a mild flavor that pairs well with cream cheese. Sourdough options shine with varied cream cheeses and fresh veggies, often lightly toasted for extra taste.

People are saying

"The sourdough bagel with tofu cream cheese was so good."

"I always go for the pumpernickel bagel here."

"The pumpernickel bagel's flavor is mild but pairs great with cream cheese."

Good to know

1

The wait time for a bagel is typically 30-45 minutes on sunny Sundays.

2

There is no seating available at the bagel shop.

3

It is better to order to-go at this bagel shop.

09
Amy's Bread image 1
Amy's Bread image 2
Amy's Bread image 3
View all
🍞 Pumpernickel Bread
🍞 Sourdough
🛋️ Cozy
🥐 Croissant
More

Small bakery with cozy, quiet atmosphere and exposed brick interior invites relaxed mornings. Seating is limited but comfortable, with some outdoor tables under red umbrellas. Offers a wide selection of breads and pastries praised for quality and flavor.

People are saying

"The sourdough breads and pastries are delicious and varied."

"I couldn't stop eating this dark, chewy sourdough bread."

"The chocolate sourdough twists are a tasty treat."

Good to know

1

The bakery does not have a restroom available for customers.

2

Expect the ham and cheese biscuits to run out quickly during busy hours.

3

Prices for coffee and quiche are around $12, making them affordable.

10
Tompkins Square Bagels | East Village Bagels image 1
Tompkins Square Bagels | East Village Bagels image 2
Tompkins Square Bagels | East Village Bagels image 3
View all
🍞 Sourdough
🍞 Pumpernickel Bread
🌱 Vegan Friendly
🥯 Bagels
More

Open kitchen fills the small space with freshly baked bagel aroma and constant activity. Atmosphere feels lively and chaotic, with a buzzing crowd and limited, crowded seating. Staff and customers contribute to a friendly, energetic vibe in a pup-friendly environment.

People are saying

"The bagels are fresh with many tasty options."

"I love pairing pumpernickel bagels with tasty spreads."

"The pumpernickel bagel felt small and mild in flavor."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times of 30-60 minutes, especially on weekends.

2

You must order quickly as there's no time to change your mind.

3

No dine-in available on weekends; it's takeout only.