Alimentari Beach Montauk

Open in the off season Wish there were a few gluten free options - there is so much good gf pasta coming out of Italy Overall better than average food but very pricey but all of MTK is $17-25 for a glass of wine The portions are generous I got a soup special and it was $17 and a really big bowl also delicious Do yourself a favor and order a side of bread $8 and served warm w delicious olive oil Skip the crab salad. Sounds delicious and it’s all fresh but it’s bland Service is usually very good It’s also super loud in there /could turn music down a little

Atmosphere is really nice and servers + staff are wonderful. The food was solid, but didn’t blow my socks off and that’s just fine. Meatballs were meatballs. Nothing too crazy here but tasted homemade and fresh. The Penne Bolognese was good, although the bottom noodles were a bit lukewarm. Most likely due to the plate not being hot enough. I don’t know why they don’t advertise that they serve gluten free pasta / pizza. Girlfriend got a gluten free spaghetti and the pasta was cooked perfectly for GF. Tasty! Would come back to get a classic Italian fix for a decent price in Montauk. Outdoor seating is nice, might get a little loud inside.