Batavia Creamery

I must say - the selection of ice cream is pretty amazing. There's a wide variety of flavors and several dairy free, vegan, gluten free options. And their cakes are pretty amazing. We have purchased a birthday cake here twice, once pre-ordered and once out of the case. There was no difference in quality between the pre-ordered cake and the one out of the case. Both were amazingly delicious! Some of their items are a little pricey, but we don't mind paying a little more for excellent quality. This ice cream shop is one of those local hidden gems that you don't want to miss when you find yourself in Batavia!! Note to the Creamery - please make brown butter bourbon one of your always flavors... you so rarely have it when I come in, and it's one of my favorites!!

Great service. SO grateful for vegan options. Now just waiting for the brownie or cookie dough to be gluten free!