Benny's Pizzeria

To anyone who has left less than a 5 star review for this place- BIG EYEROLL. I’d like to start by saying that the owner is such a delight! We had the pleasure of meeting Benny in his restaurant today. He is a passionate, selfless, hard working man who loves what he does and gives back to the community AND THAT is something to be admired and respected. Sadly, some people have nothing better to do than give bad reviews to business’s that have been operated by a family that loves their community for 30+ years because their pepperoni was upside down. The staff were all happy and helpful. We ordered a Large Sicilian chicken bacon ranch pizza and a gluten/dairy free veggie and chicken pizza. When our order first came out I noticed that my pizza had cheese on it. I ((kindly)) let Benny’s daughter know and she immediately offered to remake the pizza. I told her that they did not need to remake the pizza and that i would just have a salad. She insisted on remaking the pizza AND and a beautiful salad made for me. I was also brought a grilled chicken breast to have with the salad. The veggies, chicken and dressing was SO GOOD! Benny told me that the balsamic vinegar at dressing was made in house. I asked if i could buy some and he told me that they did not sell it but gave me two additional cups to take with me. I was still eating when my husband and girls had finished. The girls were offered ice cream once they finished. Two homemade cannolis were brought out with my brand-new pizza! We were sent home with so much food and treats at not additional cost to us. Im so grateful for the love that we were shown today. It was a wonderful experience and we will be sending recommendations to anyone we know visiting the area. Im telling you all of this to say “Don't be a jerk and you might be surprised at how people want to treat you.” There are good people in the world and we need to be good to them.

This is the home of best gluten free pizza that I’ve ever had. All toppings are garden fresh and delicious. They cook the pizza to perfection. The service is excellent, especially Dawn, who’s truly a kind and caring person. Benny’s pizza has set the bar. It’s back yard setting is beautifully landscaped and tables are spaced far apart. Great for couples and families. It’s easily the most magical pizza experience in my life. I live in Gardiner but I tell you it’s worth the drive to eat here every weekend! Keep up the magic Benny!