My husband and I have come by for dinner twice now, and had an outstanding meal both times. We've each tried a few dishes, and found that everything we tried was flavorful and the service was perfect. The staff are ready to answer questions and offer recommendations, without hovering around or interrupting you. Vegetarians and those who need gluten free dishes can find plenty of options too - these things may not be marked on the menu, but the staff will have that information for you, or you can look at the menu on their web site.
Personally, I recommend the Lamb Galouti Kebab and the Rarha Gosht with your preferred rice. Do try the sauces on the kebab, and squeezing a bit of lemon on. Also, keep in mind that they do serve some of their dishes with more spice and heat than other restaurants in the area. The flavor is more than worth the heat, but you may want some naan or a drink ready to balance it out. :)
There are multiple Indian restaurants closer to us than Broadway Masala, but we'll be coming back here instead of saving the time for a lower quality meal.