After reading some reviews, I was initially skeptical, but I am pleased to say that our experience at this restaurant was wonderful. We were greeted by a friendly hostess who accommodated our request to sit inside with a lovely view of the outdoors and the ocean. Our waiter, Mario, was super attentive and engaging, recommending the delicious burata and a beautiful wine. The gluten-free options were extensive, and my scampi and my husband's chicken parm were both delicious. Overall, it was one of the best meals I've had on the island, and I highly recommend Casa Nonna. Thank you!