We visited Good Fellows on a slow Saturday afternoon, our first visit. Started off on an iffy note, as there was no one to greet and seat us. After a couple of minutes I got the attention of the bartender and she told us to sit wherever we wanted.
W seated ourselves at a high table for four against the wall. All the walls were covered with sports and gangster movie memorabilia. I counted over 25 TV screens, all featuring golf, baseball, or the prelims for an upcoming UFC event.
The menu is extensive, featuring plenty of craft, import, and traditional beers. They have an awesome, fully stocked bar with great bourbon and scotch selections. They have Coke products and tea as well.
We ordered a twelve-inch, three ingredient pizza. There were some yummy appetizers we wanted to try, but that'll be for another visit. The hand tossed crust on the pizza was crispy on the bottom and chewy, with a good bready texture, held up its integrity for the length of our visit. I ordered a Guinness on draft, always a pleasure to find as more and more bars seem to have it only in cans. That is simply not done.
We were tempted by the menu description to order the cinnamon sticks for dessert, little more than thin pizza crust with butter and sugar and cinnamon, served with a thick icing on the side. But, v testament to the quality of the pizza crust, these were very tasty.
They have sports bar hours, which are very late on weekends. The menu features sandwiches and subs, salad, pasta, a burger, and baked wings, with some gluten free options and vegan choices here and there (a cauliflower crust for a $2 upcharge, for instance).
Visit Good Fellows and enjoy some great food.