Gluten free crust was really good. Probably the best gf pizza crust we've ever had. The regular crust was fine, and the pizza in general was fine. The Italian nachos were also fine. The problem is everything was extremely overpriced. A 10" pizza was $19. That's just silly. The nachos were equally small and overpriced. I'm guessing about 15% food cost. At that rate, they can afford servers. Which brings me to my next point.
The order by phone thing is just a bad idea. Everyone there is super friendly, and wants to provide great service. I, in turn, want to pay for great service. Taking me away from my table to pick up my food and drink is not a good thing. Get servers. Make it a night out for people. We'll pay for it.
The location is great. The outdoor seating in downtown Erie is great. Just bring your prices in line with a reasonable food cost, and add servers.