Atly
Goodfella's 1
Goodfella's 2
View all images
View all

Goodfella's

Pizza restaurant
$$Accommodating gluten-free
Delivery
Kid Friendly
Lunch
Take Away
More
This Italian eatery features a warm, inviting atmosphere with a modern interior, pristine bar, and loft VIP section. It offers excellent gluten-free options with attentive service and a convivial mood, making it a must-visit for gluten-free diners seeking comfort and quality.
User 1
User 2
User 3
User 4
191 joined today
Accommodating Icon

Accommodating

Some risk of cross-contamination

Trained staff
Suggested by the GF community
Always inquire directly about health and safety.
Menu Icon

View menu

4029 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, New York, United States
2.4km

People are saying

G
G
went on a friday night, service was very good seated right and served in a timely manner. options for gluten free and even vegan appetizers and entrees.
M
Monika Fauci
Whether you're in search of a quick bite or a leisurely dinner, this place will not disappoint. Goodfellas has found a new home and the gleaming coffered ceiling is the cherry on the icing. The banquet seating is comfortable, the mood is convivial and the staff -- attentive and friendly. There were 6 of us and the start of dinner was a loaf of home-made, freahly-baked bread along with some olive oil dip with fresh basil. For appetizers we ordered a slew of vegetables sautéed in garlic and olive oil. They were done to perfection! The garlic was soft but not burnt, the vegetables were tender but not overdone. Every entree was hot, the pasta was al dente, the pizzas were crusty yet deliciously chewy with quality toppings like smoked mozzarella, caramelized onions and roasted red pepper cream. The gluten free pizza crust is exceptional as is the pasta. For those who cannot consume gluten this place must be God-sent as many eateries just do not serve anything near as good as Goodfellas when it comes to gluten free options. The wine selection, while not huge, is more than adequate. I cannot speak for the desserts as I do not like sweets, but the rest of the party raved about the almond cake. Sophia, our server, was funny, quick-witted and attentive. Salt, pepper, water, napkins, hot honey, lemon slices.... whatever we needed she brought in a timely manner. The chef/owner makes the obligatory rounds to the tables and keeps a watchful eye on the food and staff. We will definitely be going back for the food, live music, crusty bread and relaxing atmosphere. Highly recommend!

Featured in Lists

Top 6 Gluten-Free Kid-Friendly Spots to Explore in Great Kills, New York
Top 6 Gluten-Free Late-Night Spots to Enjoy in Great Kills, New York
Top 5 Gluten-Free Lunch Spots to Enjoy in Great Kills, New York
Most reliable Celiac Map

Explore dozens of GF spots in your area

and 300k GF places worldwide!

Certificate
Built with dieticians

Vetted information about every place's celiac safety

Advanced Filters
Advanced Filters

Quickly find the exact GF restaurant you are looking for

Celiac Community
Celiac community

Reviews and tips by like minded celiacs

"I have been using it now for 3 months and it saves me so much research. Reduces the need to call and double check every time."

Kenneth M.

Kenneth M.

Gluten Intolerant

"Finding places to eat used to be such a drag. Atly made it so much easier. Love it!"

Jane G.

Jane G.

Highly symptomatic celiac

Discover 300k vetted Gluten Free places around the world!