Island Pie

This place was an Easter Dream come true. My friends and I missed our ferry while hiking, we were wet, cold and hungry. We found Island Pie for a bite while we waited for the last ferry out. What a wonderful experience it was! The place felt cozy and familiar, family owned and it felt that way. There was a child there riding a tricycle around the restaurant having the time of his life, and while this isn’t ideal for some, we found him very funny, and the overall experience extremely charming. The food was DELICIOUS. We had the gluten free crust and it was in the top 3 best crusts I’ve ever had, not to mention the toppings! We had such a memorable time here, we would definitely recommend it to our friends, and we will be visiting again!

Best gluten free pizza I've had. Eating on a nice deck on a beautiful sunny day (with the staff adjusting the umbrella for shade) made it even better.

Italian sausage and shallots pizza is my favorite! Shallots are fried perfectly and fragrant. Generous portions of toppings. I enjoy their gluten-free crust, thin and crisp. Owners are always working hard. Great people, warm and welcoming. They have a lovely patio seating overlooking the harbor.