JudyPie

Underwhelmed by the desserts at this shop. The pies were either hard as a rock (to the point of the "filling" crumbling to ash) or soup-like mush. The cookies were stale and the pie flavors were too subdued to enjoy. The only good buy was the Reese's pie. It was simply delicious. The woman who assisted me was attentive and fast; she even gave me a 6" key lime pie because the slice I'd ordered was unavailable as the pie from which to cut it had already been sold. Despite her good service, I will not be back, not only for the poor quality of products but due to the owner's complete lack of professionalism. Word to the wise, read the owner's responses to customers who were dissatisfied with their service or the food. That alone would have kept me away had I read them prior. Update in response to the owner's reply: Your menu does indeed show you offer Gluten Free Reese's pie... that would be peanut butter. As stated in my review, it was the only pie that was good.

Great key lime pie! Friendly employees and nice ambiance. They have gluten free and vegan options, too!