We went to Matthew's 1600 for the Thanksgiving buffet. Reservations were required, but I had no issue with that a few weeks in advance. I think the price was on par with most buffets. Gratuity was included in our bill already. They had simple white lights and flowers to decorate and the buffet line went smoothly. There were a variety of options, including vegetarian and gluten free dishes. My favorite was the seafood pasta (crab and shrimp with cream sauce and penne). They included a carving station, which is a nice touch. The dessert table had multiple options from cake to pudding. Overall, the experience was very nice. They do have a handicapped entrance, but please be aware that there are also a lot of stairs on the other side of the restaurant.