This was our first visit to a Mellow Mushroom - and truth be told we picked it b/c it was the only restaurant on the Island w/o a long line or wait. And my kids (5 & 10) will ALWAYS go for Pizza. It was very good; very hot and brought out quickly. The prices were a bit high for pizza but on vacation, that's expected. A good, quick option for a quick and easy meal w/ a family and they even had a gluten free pizza, which I appreciated. I stuck w/ 4 stars simply because it was a serve yourself, bus your own table kind of restaurant; but all of the staff we encountered were very pleasant.