Pastaloni

A hidden gem in Garden city. If you are craving authentic Italian food this is the place. I just came back from Italy and this place was the closest to the food we’ve had there. All ingredients are made from scratch and absolutely delicious. We got the Gluten-free Alfredo, steak Al fungi, combinazioni , pesto gnocchi, polo pizza, eggplant rolls and spicy meatballs. I wasn’t a huge fan of eggplant rolls but everything else was incredible. Each dish had its own homemade sauce that was perfection. The sauce for the Alfredo and spicy meatballs were my favorite. The mushroom sauce on the steak was soooo delicious and Alfredo was the best I’ve had. The chef was so kind and thoughtful. He helped guide us on what to order and checked on us multiple times to see how we were enjoying the food and to see if we need anything. He was very attentive. The ambiance of the entire restaurant was a vibe. The restaurant itself was very clean and so were the bathrooms. I will absolutely be back here.

Service was wonderful, everyone was very kind and welcoming. I have celiac disease and was informed that they can make a gluten free pasta dish as well, you just need to call ahead. I enjoyed the risotto with a substitution of salmon instead of chicken. Risotto was delicious and the perfect texture, not watery as risotto can be when cooked by an unskilled person. Staff was very kind to my group (we accidentally stayed past closing) and never made us feel like a burden. Also they’re adding a coffee bar soon which will be just the perfect addition. All food was halal as well which was just amazing.