This is the definition of the hole-in-the-wall place that locals know about (or should know about) and we're kinda glad to keep it to ourselves.
Three of us went for a work lunch and split two pizzas and three salads. I eat gluten-free so I was THRILLED to find a 10" gluten-free option. My pizza crust was just crisp enough, which is hard to do gluten-free, and had a good taste and most importantly it held all the ingredients, again hard to do gluten-free.
The pizza toppings were fresh, with mushrooms and peppers that did not come frozen or from a can and they were very flavorful. The sauce and cheese were abundant. Not a bite remains!
Our salad portions were big, it could have been a meal in and of itself. My chef salad was delicious with ample portions of provel, ham, bacon and pepperoni.
There are two indoor dining tables, and Pie O My shares a semi-covered outdoor space with the tavern next door, so we'll enjoy sitting outside next time we come.
The workers there were friendly and treated us nicely.
Really happy to find a new favorite pizza place.