Pros: Outstanding views of Central Park and Columbus Circle. Aesthetically beautiful and wonderfully decorated; fun, colorful, romantic and very intimate/private. Great service from an accommodating, friendly and professional staff. Inexpensive. Non-alcoholic options available. Free small bites for the table. Vegan, gluten free, and vegetarian options. Homemade ice cream and sorbets! Large portion sizes.
Cons: No parking. Tight dining space. Limited/small menu. Food was okay/good; the braised lamb fell apart like butter, but flavor wise could have used some seasoning. The restaurant is labeled as Modern Classic American Cuisine but I struggled to find any dishes on the dinner menu that felt familiar or in this style.
Ribollita: 3/5
Crab Cakes: 4/5
Brussel Sprouts: 3/5
Braised Lamb: 3/5
Scottish Salmon: 3/5
Pistachio Crème Brûlée: 2/5
Raspberry ice cream: 5/5
Overall, I enjoyed dining at Robert. I would like to return to try brunch or lunch, and I would even try dinner again; overall I think the menu was interesting, ideal for those that are looking to try something new, without bold or overwhelming flavor. I would also love to experience a musical event, which they schedule regularly!