We stopped for breakfast while visiting the finger lakes. Simply Jimmy’s is homey and has a big menu. Overall we were most impressed with the service. There was one server who was able to take care of the entire place by herself. She did an amazing job. Another plus was brunch time on a weekday and they were happy to make breakfast or lunch. We decided on a Sicilian panini, they were able to make it on gluten free bread, and a garbage plate. The sandwich was good and I was thrilled they offered sweet potato fries. The garbage plate came out with a raw, still frozen burger. The server apologized, took it back and had it remade. She was also kind enough to take it off the check. Overall not a bad experience but not sure how the cook didn’t notice sending out a frozen burger.