Sugar River Pizza Co. - New Glarus

Our group had three different pizzas including one gluten-free and they were all delicious. We were visiting the town and this place was recommended by a local. We ate the leftovers the next night.

Giving them three stars because they do have quite a few menu options, including a couple that are gluten free. The scores are low because of a couple of issues: 1) I ordered a gluten free sandwich for my child. Not only did it come out burned, but the (same) server also walked over and plonked down a GLUTEN cookie next to the gluten-free sandwich I’d just ordered. If my child’s allergy had been severe, handing her a gluten cookie to go with her gluten-free meal could truly be dangerous. Plus, have you ever tried to take a cookie away from a child? I mentioned (very respectfully) to the server that a gluten free child can’t have a gluten cookie for safety reasons, and she didn’t apologize—she just blamed the kitchen and walked away. This didn’t make anything better (and I still had an upset child). 2) Both meals (hers, burned and the gluten issue; and mine, a pizza), made us feel icky afterwards. Flavor was not great; very processed and WAY too salty. We were hopeful but won’t be back. For the safety of others, I hope they learn to be sensitive to these topics (and burned sandwiches are never good, regardless). I wish them well.