We have never once had an experience here that was anything other than great! Sunday's is a must, and really steps up to the plate for those of us who like to mix it up and try new things... In addition to more traditional flavors, they offer a great variety of more inventive flavors (Double Dunker, Party Cake, Coconut, and Death by Chocolate are all amazing), they also have vegan, gluten free, and dairy free ice cream options, plus Italian ice so good my husband won't get it anywhere else! There's also a huge selection of toppings, dips, etc, and I can't overstate the quality of the ice cream. If you're lucky enough to be served by the owner, she is incredibly nice, friendly, and openly excited to tell you all about the flavors, and to help with any allergy questions or concerns. Absolutely love this place!!
Price-wise - we were literally just there this evening, got a large Italian ice and a large two-flavor ice cream. $12. $6 each is VERY reasonable, I think...
And yes, the vanilla ice cream is dog friendly!