I used to come to the Meatball Shop when I was in grad school in 2012/2013. It was wonderful then! BUT it was TERRIBLE yesterday. I usually don't write reviews but I want to make sure people understand how bad their food is. I ordered the chicken meatballs and they were undercooked, pink and raw inside. It smelled funny too. I ordered it on a bed of kale (worst decision ever) because they kale was sautéed but tasted rotten. Yuck. My husband who is gluten free ordered the chicken one too because that was the only one gf and he was nauseous and sick that night. He has bouts of nausea and a severe migraine because of the food. Thankfully I was already on a strong course of antibiotics for something else, so I was not affected as much. This was my first trip to NYC after 12 years and I was looking forward to eating here. BIG MISTAKE.