The Oyster Society

Seafood restaurant
Accommodating gluten-free
Dinner
Seafood
Take Away
Outdoor Seating
More
This venue offers a cozy vibe with live weekend jazz and a beautiful outdoor bar, creating a welcoming atmosphere. It is very accommodating to gluten-free diets, with a clearly labeled menu and attentive service ensuring a safe, enjoyable dining experience for gluten-sensitive guests.
Accommodating Icon

Accommodating

Some risk of cross-contamination

Trained staff
Checked by Atly
Always inquire directly about health and safety.

Good to know

1

The menu identifies all gluten-free options for easy ordering.

2

Reservations are recommended about a week in advance.

3

Happy hour is only available at the bar.

599 S Collier Blvd #218, Marco Island, FL 34145, USA
2.4km

People are saying

W
Went with high expectations after reading the reviews and blogs about the place and the happy hour. Coming from DC, I had high expectations of the food and service (especially with the prices). The fish was fresh and s good portion but the flavors were ok at best. The blackened fish was more salt than spice and overall flavor was ok. The house salad was a good attempt but flavors laid flat. The rest of the meals at our table were simply ok. No value for the prices. Drinks were way over priced. Lastly, the staff needs MAJOR training. Our waitor was nice and tried his best but I don't think he understood half of what we said. We had a gluten allergy at the table and let him know. The menu identified all gf options - so that was easy but we were specific on the salad to ensure no croutons. The salad came out with croutons and had to be returned. And at the end he gave us the wrong bill (one for another table). The manager popped by and I kindly shared the gf challenge and his response was thank you. He was more concerned being part of the social arena. The happy hour situation is not one i would recommend. The bar area is small in comparison to the restaurant with VERY limited seating and happy hour is only available at the bar. The bar area was filled up. None of the happy hour options were available in the dining room. I understand the food part but certainly not on the drinks. Overall...not worth the money.
S
A very nicely appointed restaurant with an incredibly good menu selection and our service was first rate. I definitely recommend this restaurant, especially if you are on a gluten free diet. They are very accommodating.

Featured in Lists

Top 38 Gluten-Free Spots Across Marco Island
Top 38 Gluten-Free Spots Across City of Marco, Marco Island
Top 33 Gluten-Free Spots with Outdoor Seating to Enjoy in Marco Island