The Pie

We had an incredible dinner here. Everything from start to finish was perfect. The food was amazing, fresh, and full of flavor, and the desserts were truly next-level, the kind of indulgent, homemade perfection you dream about. A special shoutout to Rachel, our server, who made the entire experience exceptional. She was warm, attentive, and incredibly accommodating of my girlfriend's gluten-free diet, offering thoughtful suggestions and making sure every detail was just right. It’s rare to find someone who makes you feel both genuinely cared for and well taken care of in a busy restaurant. Rachel absolutely did. Between the delicious food, the charming atmosphere, and the outstanding service, The Pie of Port Jefferson has become one of my favorite spots on Long Island. Highly recommend for anyone looking for great food, decadent desserts, and exceptional hospitality!

The Pie is a must visit if you are looking for a cozy Italian place with amazing service and delicious food! My husband is gluten intolerant, and our server Rachel was so incredibly accommodating, making sure to ask clarifying questions and offer appropriate alternatives so that we both felt comfortable. She really made the lovely atmosphere even more fun, and I hope to visit both The Pie and Rachel again when we are back in town!