Visited the Port Renfrew after visiting the Botanical Beach just looking for coffee. Turns out The Renfrew Pub was the only place open due to a power outage because they had a generator. Wasn't expecting more than drip coffee - but was pleasantly surprised with all the cafe options they had! Definitely one of the best mochas I've had.
Waitress also went above and beyond to find out whether or not my celiac boyfriend could eat certain things on the menu. Turns out the fish tacos were the safest bet and he loved them. I got the seared tuna, which was okay.
Pretty pricey, but how often are you in Port Renfrew? Worth a stop for the experience alone.