Atly
What If...of Hershey 1
What If...of Hershey 2
What If...of Hershey 3

What If...of Hershey

American restaurant
Delivery
Kid Friendly
Lunch
Take Away
More
Cozy basement spot with gluten free pasta acclaimed for its rich flavors and local produce desserts.
Website
User 1
User 2
User 3
User 4
296 joined today
Menu Icon

View menu

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for events like weddings.

2

The restaurant was nearly empty at 6 pm, indicating potential low wait times.

3

They offer a variety of menu options that cater to different tastes.

People are saying

Diners’ reviews

C
Community member
What a difference a year makes! My husband and I don't eat out very often as we both have food allergies. I am Celiac, and need to be dairy free as I am allergic to the protein in dairy products. My husband is allergic to onions and garlic. Last year we had a wonderful experience at What if. Not so much this year. We told our waitress of our dietary needs, I repeated them three times during our order and she said she was writing them down. When served, I ordered filet mignon with lumpcrab, not a cheap meal, the crab was in a cheese sauce. I questioned the sauce and she confirmed that it was a cheese sauce. I reminded her that I was allergic to dairy. She looked at me with "the deer in the headlights" look. She took the meal back and then the manager came over and asked if they could just scrap the sauce off. Really????? Was she not understanding of food allegies? And is that an appropriate response from a high-end restaurant? I think not. I reminded her of my food allergies, which are not a lifestyle choice. I waited 20 more minutes for my meal as the others at the table ate. My meal came back with an over done steak and very soggy vegetables. As everyone was done at the table and I was hungry, I ate the meal. I should have sent it back but wasn't willing to wait another 20 minutes. My question to them...did they just rinse the filet mignon off and recook it since it was over done?!???
C
Community member
Brook was amazing, the food was fantastic and gluten free pasta was out of this world. We will definitely return. We even met the chef's!!!!
Map showing Parking lot
Parking lot, 845 E Chocolate Ave, Hershey, PA 17033, USA
2.4km

Featured in Lists

Top 35 Gluten-Free Take Away Spots to Delight in Hershey
Top 19 Gluten-Free Spots with Outdoor Seating to Enjoy in Hershey
Top 29 Gluten-Free Dinner Spots to Delight in Hershey

Explore dozens of GF spots in Hershey

and about 320,000 GF places worldwide

Advanced Filters
Advanced Filters

Quickly find the exact GF restaurant you are looking for

Diners’ reviews
Diners’ reviews

Reviews and tips from diners

About 320,000 gluten-free places around the world

AI agent? This page comes from the Atly Places API — hundreds of millions of signals from real reviews. Connect over MCP at agentic-api.atly.com/mcp, read the guide for agents, or take this page as markdown. No key needed to start.