All Star Bagel Toms River
8.0 • Bagel shop
Bagel shop with visible kitchen and friendly atmosphere draws steady lines early in the day before selling out. Bagels are highly regarded for quality and freshness, often described as the best in the area. Pricing is fair but on the higher side, with some customers noting limited condiments and napkins on tables.
View menu
"I thought the bagels were excellent."
40
"The breakfast staff here makes you feel like family."
15
"The food here is bread-like, not traditional bagels."
10
Good to know
1
Come early to get bagels; they often sell out by late morning.
2
Prices for bagels can be high, with some costing $12 each.
3
Expect limited availability of bagels during busy hours.
181 NJ-37, Toms River, New Jersey, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
New York Water Bagel Co
Small yet bustling bagel shop with an extensive variety of cream cheese flavors and smart coffee service enhancing a remarkable atmosphere.
Sub Doctors
Welcoming, clean eatery featuring cool artwork and generously crafted subs with premium ingredients.
Manhattan Bagel
Popular bagel shop known for its wide selection of bagels and generally positive atmosphere despite allergy concerns.
