Bagel Cafe
7.8 • Bagel shop
Cozy space with booths for eating in offers a pleasant, discreet atmosphere. Bagels come fresh from the oven with a soft texture and well-done flavor, including Asiago and generous lox cream options. Prices are generally good, with amazing bagel deals available, though early morning variety is limited.
View menu
"I found the bagels to be amazing and delicious."
10
"The breakfast foods here were superb and the staff went above and beyond."
6
"I ordered a sausage, egg, and cheese scrambled on a plain bagel."
3
Good to know
1
Prices for a dozen bagels are competitive compared to other local shops.
2
The cafe opens at 6:00am, but not all items are available until later.
3
Expect limited bagel varieties early in the morning, especially before 7:00am.
187 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, New York, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Bagels 101
Local favorite known for high-quality New York-style bagels with a reputation for excellent catering services.
Barnwood Market
Well-merchandised small deli offering quality sandwiches with a distinctive 'life’s tight and we eat right' ethos.
Rocky Point Road Deli
Clean, welcoming deli known for its generous heroes, diverse breakfast, salads, and soups in a friendly atmosphere.
