Bagels By The Bay🥯
8.6 • Bagel shop
Small shop with authentic New York vibes offers fresh, handmade bagels and an amazing cream cheese selection. The atmosphere feels cozy and welcoming, with meticulous displays and a friendly energy. It often gets crowded, reflecting its popularity for breakfast and lunch.
View menu
"The bagels here are always fresh and delicious."
25
"The staff here makes breakfast feel so warm and friendly."
13
"I was surprised by how incredible the Reuben sandwich was."
8
Good to know
1
The shop is small and can get crowded, especially on weekends.
2
They offer a variety of cream cheeses to choose from.
3
Prices are reasonable and affordable for most customers.
1231 Bay St, Staten Island, New York, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Montalbano's
Family-run Italian specialty store featuring a wide selection of imported foods in a clean, inviting atmosphere.
Avocado Sushi
Intimate, spotlessly clean sushi spot with a quiet ambiance and charming, sticker-adorned seating area.
Fire Grilled Burgers
Laid-back burger joint known for hot, fast delivery and consistently clean, inviting atmosphere.
