Bennett Shellfish
9.1 • Seafood market
Takeaway-only seafood market with a cute cottage design and mom-and-pop feel. Atmosphere is authentic and inviting, reflecting a family-run tradition spanning generations. Known for fresh lobster rolls and smoked fish spread, it operates on a cash-only basis with no seating available.
View menu
"The seafood here is always so fresh, especially the oysters."
116
"I had the best lobster roll I’ve ever tasted here."
53
"I found this place to be a terrific hidden gem."
3
Good to know
1
Bennett Shellfish is takeout only and accepts cash only.
2
There is no seating area available at Bennett Shellfish.
3
The lobster rolls are priced at a fraction of the tourist spots in Montauk.
2 S Debusy Rd, Montauk, New York, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Montauk Seafood Company
Family-owned seafood market offering fresh, reasonably priced seafood with complementary lemon, butter, and sauces.
MTK Lobster House
Charming, quaint seafood spot with indoor and outdoor seating, featuring a casual, clean, and restful ambiance.
Viking Fleet
Beautiful, clean vessel offering amazing views of humpback whales and dolphins, with expert captains guiding to prime fishing spots.
