Brother's Pizzeria
8.7 • Pizza restaurant
Old school pizza restaurant with cash-only policy and authentic Italian decor featuring a spacious, well-lit dining area. Atmosphere is busy and energetic, often loud with casual vibes and a nostalgic New York feel. Regulars enjoy the highly regarded pizza and lively counter service.
View menu
"I thought Brother's Pizzeria served some of the best pizza I had ever tasted."
36
"The Italian food here, especially the vodka slice, is the best."
9
"I've always been able to find parking available here."
3
Good to know
1
You need to bring cash as Brothers only accepts cash.
2
The only working bathroom is filthy and raises hygiene concerns.
3
Customers cannot sit and eat inside the restaurant after 9:25 PM.
750 Port Richmond Ave, Staten Island, New York, United States
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
La Bella Pizza
Bright, clean environment offering a wide variety of affordable, tasty pizzas with attentive service.
Piccolo Pinos Pizzeria
Long-standing pizzeria known for over 30 pizza varieties and a clean, comfy ambiance with consistent quality.
Michaelangelos Pizzeria
Casual pizzeria known for its amazing sauce and consistently fast delivery, offering good value slices.
