Cait's Key Lime
8.9 • Bakery
Online bakery specializes in small-batch key lime pies with gluten-free and nut-free options. Pies balance tart and creamy flavors without excessive sweetness and maintain quality for days. Strong focus on fresh, carefully sourced ingredients and dedicated craftsmanship defines the experience.
View menu
"I thought this Key Lime Pie was the best I'd ever had."
52
"I thought Cait's key lime pie was the best dessert I ever had."
17
"I thought the gluten-free key lime pie was delicious."
6
Good to know
1
Cait's Key Lime is an online business; follow their Instagram for updates.
2
The pie comes with a gluten-free crust option and is nut-free.
3
I recommend visiting Cait's website to order some pie.
Willoughby Street & Jay Street, Brooklyn, New York, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Krispy Krunchy Chicken
Casual eatery known for reasonably priced fried chicken with a notably sweet batter and generous portions.
Stack'd Burger
Cozy, spotless open kitchen eatery with a welcoming atmosphere and flavorful, juicy burgers under $15.
Dave's Hot Chicken
Cozy, art-adorned small dining space with a cheerful atmosphere and the aroma of freshly fried chicken.
