Carlo's Pizza Shirley
7.4 • Pizza restaurant
Pizza restaurant features a giant pizza oven and offers diverse pizza by the slice alongside lunch and dinner entrees. Atmosphere is positive and friendly with helpful staff and reasonable pricing. The place stands out for authentic New York City-style pizza and expanded menu options beyond just pizza.
View menu
"I thought the pizza here was authentic New York City style."
53
"The food here is delicious and always amazing."
27
Good to know
1
The price for a slice of pizza varies between $2 and $9 depending on the staff.
2
You can make additions to your order up to 2 hours before delivery.
3
The restaurant has a sit-down menu available for dining in.
451 Glen Dr, Shirley, New York, United States
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Joes Pizza Restaurant (Shirley NY)
Old-school New York pizza spot with fair prices, a clean setting, and an on-point vibe.
Savarona's Pizzeria
Clean, well-regarded pizzeria known for its quality catering and consistent customer satisfaction.
M&M pizzeria
Quality pizzeria known for fresh ingredients and a variety of consistently good menu options.
