Cookie Jar
9.2 • Cookie shop
Cookie shop with whimsical cookie jar displays and a clean, fun atmosphere filled with the smell of butter, sugar, vanilla, and chocolate. Offers a vast selection of high-quality cookies and pastries, including unique flavors like raspberry coconut and salted caramel brownies. Known for perfectly balanced textures in cookies, combining gooey centers with crispy edges.
View menu
"I thought the cookies here were the best I've ever had."
28
"I thought the cupcakes were excellent and not too sweet."
5
"The bakery's cookies and cupcakes are excellent and not too sweet."
5
Good to know
1
The bakery offers a wide variety of unique cookies, cupcakes, and milkshakes.
2
Expect to pay around $38 for 8 cupcakes.
3
Parking can be tough for handicapped individuals.
1226 Forest Ave, Staten Island, New York, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
CakeChef
Renowned bakery offering beautifully executed cakes and a diverse selection of high-quality pastries at fair prices.
The Sweet Life Bakeshop
Cozy, community-minded bakery offering an impressive variety of gluten-free treats and affordable coffee in a welcoming atmosphere.
Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe
Renowned bakery featuring beautiful displays of fresh pastries, tarts, cookies, pies, and cakes with a reputation for custom cakes.
