Fireside Caterer
7.6 • Deli
Large space offers plenty of menu options including hot and cold foods and daily specials. Atmosphere feels welcoming with a classic deli vibe. Sandwiches and egg dishes stand out as notably good among typical New York deli offerings.
View menu
"You'll find the best sandwiches at this deli."
16
"I found the egg sandwiches outstanding."
2
"I think the chicken cutlet Parmesan hero is the best Lunch Spot I ever had."
1
Good to know
1
Reservations are not accepted; it's first-come, first-served.
2
Expect long wait times during peak lunch hours, especially on weekends.
3
Payment is required upfront; credit cards are accepted.
513 Old Country Rd #4903, Plainview, New York, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Gold & Meyer's Gourmet Deli
Clean, fast deli offering breakfast with muffins, danishes, and bagels, featuring limited front seating and outdoor views of planes.
Cravings Home of Dugan’s Cafe
Elegant, cozy eatery blending an Italian-style deli and market with a salad and coffee bar in a welcoming atmosphere.
Dugan’s Sandwich Shop
Casual sandwich shop known for hearty roast beef sandwiches in a sunny, straightforward atmosphere.
