Johnny's Pizzeria
8.6 • Pizza restaurant
Old-school pizzeria with Yankees decor and family business photos creates a cozy, nostalgic atmosphere. The vibe feels warm and family-friendly, reflecting a traditional hometown pizza joint. Cash-only policy and complimentary valet parking add to its distinctive character.
View menu
"The Italian food here has a super thin and crispy crust."
26
"I found their thin crust pizza to be amazing and worth dying for."
19
"Parking is tricky; the lot is small and tough to navigate."
6
Good to know
1
Johnny's Pizzeria only accepts cash payments.
2
Parking around Johnny's Pizzeria is limited.
3
There is free valet parking available, which may vary depending on the night.
30 W Lincoln Ave, Mt Vernon, New York, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Anthony's Pizza
Charming old-school pizza shop known as a hidden gem with an amazing, diverse menu.
Pizza King
Casual eatery known for generous portions, tasty food, and attentive service with ample seating or takeout options.
Pizza Hut
Newly opened, clean and well-organized pizza spot delivering consistently quality food and great service.
