Lenny's Pizzeria
8.6 • Pizza restaurant
Old-school Italian pizzeria with original decor and a welcoming atmosphere. Serves classic Brooklyn-style pizza with fresh, scratch-made sauce and standout zeppoles. Cash-only policy adds to the traditional vibe.
View menu
"I thought the pizza here tasted like old school New York pizza."
25
"The Italian food's sauce and mozzarella were excellent."
9
"The food here has a classic taste, like I remember from childhood."
7
Good to know
1
On Wednesdays, they have a deal of 2 pies for 25 dollars.
2
Customers need to bring cash because there is no card machine.
3
The pizza starts at 4 dollars.
594 5th Ave, Brooklyn, New York, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Roma Pizza
Charming, nostalgic interior with picture frames and booths, serving fresh, quality ingredients in a cash-only pizzeria.
Pizza Plus
Family-owned Italian eatery featuring affordable, large thin-crust pizzas and a peaceful backyard dining area.
Pizza Town
Classic old school Italian pizza shop with a friendly vibe, spacious seating, and attentive staff in a clean, air-conditioned setting.
