Magic Fountain
9.6 • Ice cream shop
Ice cream shop with an old-fashioned charm and homemade, local flavors offers intense, less sweet ice cream that draws crowds even in extreme cold. The atmosphere is friendly and lively, especially on weekend nights, with a system to manage lines and an order-ahead option for convenience.
View menu
"I thought the ice cream here was the best I ever had."
27
"This ice cream shop has so many yummy and unique flavors."
10
"I tried various unique flavors, like Kulfi and Cookie Monster."
8
Good to know
1
Ice cream costs $8 for one scoop, which is considered pricey by some.
2
There is a line out the door even late at night, especially during busy seasons.
3
They have an order-ahead option with a convenient pick-up window.
9825 Main Rd, Mattituck, New York, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Pattys Berries and Bunches
Charming farmstand with pick-your-own berries, vibrant flower fields, and fresh, locally sourced produce in a welcoming, shaded setting.
Pookaberry Cafe
Eclectic, steampunk-inspired decor with vibrant pop art and quirky displays complements a unique Filipino fusion dining experience.
